S.Africa: Grounds of assessment held to be unreasonable

… the grounds of assessment were unreasonable in two respects, namely the incorrect utilisation of the Net Asset Value (NAV) methodology and the Commissioner’s valuation of the shares as nil:

This judgment is useful for arguing against unreasonable conduct by Revenue agencies when they issue TP assessments without following the OECD TPGs on methodologies.

Related Articles

S.Africa: Summary of the Davis Tax Committee’s BEPS Sub-committee General Report released December 2014

Summary of the Davis Tax Committee’s BEPS Sub-committee General Report released December 2014 by Peter Dachs of ENS Introduction This note provides a summary of

Portugal vs A Mining SA: Transfer Pricing Case

The case concerns a tax dispute between A…, S.A., a Portuguese mining company, and AT – Tax and Customs Authority. At the heart of the issue was the sale of an industrial wash plant by A… to B…, S.A., at a symbolic price of €1. AT contended that the sale breached transfer pricing principles under Article 58 of the IRC Code.