This decision follows an earlier decision in principle released on 7 August 2026, in which the Upper Tribunal dismissed the appeal on grounds 1 and 2 but found that the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) had erred on ground 3, concerning the quantum of daily penalties, by applying para 49A Sch 36 FA 2008, a provision the Upper Tribunal held was not applicable to the facts (paras 1-2).
The Tribunal invited written submissions on whether the quantum issue should be remitted to the FTT or remade by the Upper Tribunal itself (para 3). HMRC filed submissions on 1 September 2026 and the Appellants filed submissions, albeit late, on 23 September 2026, which the Tribunal agreed to consider (paras 4-5).
Both parties agreed that the Upper Tribunal should remake the decision on quantum rather than remit it to the FTT, and the Tribunal accepted this course (para 6).
The Appellants, David Hill and David McCracken, were pension scheme administrators who were issued with information notices requesting 13 items, none of which they complied with (paras 7-8).
They were subsequently issued with three tranches of daily penalties: the first at £30 per day after approximately three months of non-compliance, the second at £60 per day after approximately seven and a half months of non-compliance, and the third at £60 per day after approximately 13 months of non-compliance (para 7).
Prior to the second and third tranches, the Appellants had received £300 penalty notices warning that continued non-compliance could trigger further penalties of up to £60 per day (para 8(2)).
The dispute concerned the correct quantum of the daily penalties, given that the FTT's original decision had referenced an inapplicable statutory provision (para 49A Sch 36 FA 2008).
HMRC submitted that the penalties should be maintained at £30 per day for the first tranche and £60 per day for the second and third tranches, relying on the seriousness and duration of the non-compliance, the prior warnings given, and the policy purpose of daily penalties in encouraging compliance, citing Cotswold Financial Planning Ltd v HMRC [2021] UKFTT 198 (TC) at [90] (para 8).
The Appellants accepted that their reliance on advisors did not amount to a reasonable excuse, but argued that it should still reduce the quantum of penalties. They submitted that the existence of 13 outstanding information requests did not equate to 13 separate instances of serious or deliberate non-compliance, and that the escalation to £60 per day required justification beyond mere continued non-compliance. They maintained their earlier position before the FTT that £10 per day would be appropriate (para 9).
The Tribunal noted that, in refusing permission to appeal, the FTT had confirmed that the incorrect reference to para 49A Sch 36 FA 2008 did not form part of its actual decision on quantum, which was instead based on the evidence set out at [83]-[87] of the FTT decision. The Upper Tribunal placed considerable weight on this, given that the FTT had heard all the evidence (para 10).
Nonetheless, the Upper Tribunal considered that some reduction in the penalties was warranted to recognise the Appellants' reliance on their advisors, notwithstanding that this reliance did not amount to a reasonable excuse eliminating penalties altogether (para 11).
The Tribunal concluded that the first and second tranches of penalties should each be set at £30 per day, and the third tranche at £60 per day, on the basis that by the time of the third tranche the Appellants ought to have realised that they needed to reassess the advice they were receiving (para 11).
The Upper Tribunal set aside the FTT's decision on quantum and remade it, fixing the first and second tranches of daily penalties at £30 per day and the third tranche at £60 per day (para 11).
HMRC were directed to recalculate the penalties on this basis and serve the calculation on the Appellants within 21 days of release of the decision, with a view to the parties agreeing the quantum. If the parties could not agree, they had liberty to apply to the Tribunal to settle the amount (para 12).
The Appellants had submitted that no order for costs should be made. The Tribunal noted that the time limit for any costs application would run from the release of this decision, and that the Appellants would have an opportunity to respond to any costs application made by HMRC (para 13).