This decision concerns an application made by the Appellants, Edenshire Jewellery & Watches Limited (in liquidation) and Mr Liam Hugh, for directions listing a preliminary issue hearing in their joined appeals against a schedule 24 Finance Act 2007 penalty and an associated personal liability notice (PLN) [1].
The application was determined on the papers, without an oral hearing, Tribunal Judge Brooks having regard to the overriding objective and the fact that the grounds, HMRC's response and the Appellants' reply were all fully set out in writing [3].
The Tribunal, applying the principles in Wrottesley v HMRC [2015] UKUT 637 (TCC), concluded that the proposed preliminary issue was succinct and discrete, capable of disposing of the appeals or resolving the sole live issue, and suitable for a half-day hearing without significant delay [22]-[24]. The application was granted and directions were given for the listing of a preliminary hearing [25].
On 13 December 2024, HMRC issued a penalty assessment under schedule 24 Finance Act 2007 against Edenshire on the basis that it had deliberately submitted inaccurate returns by failing to declare a liability under s 455 CTA [5]. On the same date, HMRC issued Mr Liam Hugh with a PLN under paragraph 19(1) schedule 24 Finance Act 2007 in respect of that penalty [6].
Edenshire and Mr Hugh appealed to the Tribunal on 5 November 2025, contending that while other inaccuracies in Edenshire's returns may have been deliberate, the s 455 CTA inaccuracy was not deliberate because neither Edenshire nor Mr Hugh knew of the s 455 CTA liability, so HMRC had not discharged its burden of proof [7].
The two appeals were joined on 4 February 2026 [8]. HMRC filed a Combined Statement of Case (SOC) on 27 March 2026, describing the sole live issue as whether the inaccuracies giving rise to the s 455 CTA charges were deliberate within schedule 24 FA 2007 [9].
The Appellants' application, dated 28 August 2026, sought a preliminary hearing on whether a schedule 24 penalty calculated by reference to a s 455 CTA liability can be deliberate where HMRC does not allege the taxpayer knew of the s 455 liability and deliberately omitted it, together with suspension of the directions for exchange of witness statements [1]. HMRC opposed the application, responding in writing on 11 September 2026, with the Appellants replying on 29 September 2026 [2], [3].
The Appellants argued that, in light of Gopaul v HMRC [2023] UKFTT 728 (TC) and the absence, in HMRC's statement of case, of any allegation that Edenshire or Mr Hugh knew of the s 455 CTA liability and deliberately omitted it, HMRC's pleaded case could not succeed as a matter of law. They sought a preliminary hearing to determine whether Gopaul should be followed [20].
HMRC contended that the application was based on a mischaracterisation of its pleaded case. HMRC's position, as set out in the SOC, was that the relevant deliberate inaccuracy was the knowing omission of substantial trading income from Edenshire's statutory accounts and returns, and that the resulting s 455 CTA liability arose automatically and derivatively once that accounting inaccuracy was corrected, without any separate allegation of deliberate intent regarding the s 455 liability itself [11], [21].
The Tribunal applied the principles summarised by the Upper Tribunal in Wrottesley v HMRC at [28], including that the power to order a preliminary hearing should be used sparingly and only where there is a succinct, knockout point capable of disposing of the case or a separate aspect of it [19].
The Tribunal noted that in Gopaul v HMRC, the First-tier Tribunal had held that the burden of proving deliberate understatement of a s 455 CTA liability rested with HMRC, and that HMRC needed to prove the taxpayer knew of the s 455 liability and intentionally omitted it, rejecting a submission that knowledge of taking money from the company sufficed [14]-[16].
Having considered the Wrottesley principles and the overriding objective, the Tribunal concluded that the issue concerning the s 455 CTA liability and whether the inaccuracies giving rise to it were deliberate was a succinct and discrete legal issue. Its determination, given the conclusion in Gopaul, could dispose of the appeals or at least resolve the sole live issue identified in the SOC [22]-[23]. The Tribunal also found that such a hearing could be listed without delay and was unlikely to require more than half a day of Tribunal time [24].
The application was granted [22], [25(1)]. The directions issued on 20 June 2026 were suspended until further direction [25(2)]. The Tribunal directed the parties to liaise on dates for a half-day preliminary hearing commencing on 7 December 2026 or as soon as possible thereafter, and set a timetable for notification of hearing format, exchange of document lists, skeleton arguments and an electronic bundle [25(3)-(8)]. Provision was also made for any party to apply to amend, suspend or set aside the directions [25(9)].