Academy of taxlaw.
Register your interest

Tell us where you’re headed

We’ll confirm by email and a programme advisor will be in touch. We’ll also add you to the Academy newsletter (sent via Mailchimp) — every email includes a one-click unsubscribe.

Case summary · 6 November 2026

Education Training Collective v The Commissioners for HMRC

VATTax AdministrationTax Court Procedure
Section 80 VATASection 83(1)(t) VATAMarleasing PrincipleReemtsma PrincipleConforming InterpretationRetained EU LawSection 28(5) Finance Act 2024Strike OutRule 8(2)(a)PrecedentEarlsferry Thistle Golf ClubJurisdictionUnduly Paid VATZero RatingInsolvency Of Supplier

Judgment summary

The Appellant, a provider of education and training, had paid VAT charged by a construction company on a supply later confirmed by HMRC to be zero-rated. After the supplier entered administration without refunding the VAT, the Appellant asked HMRC to repay the VAT directly, relying on the EU law Reemtsma principle that a purchaser must be able to recover unduly paid VAT from the tax authority where recovery from the supplier is impossible or excessively difficult.

HMRC refused, and after review maintained that section 80 VATA permits claims only by the supplier, not the purchaser, so its decision was not an appealable decision under section 80 and the Tribunal had no jurisdiction under section 83(1)(t) VATA.

The Tribunal held, as a preliminary issue, that it had no jurisdiction. It found that the conforming interpretation of section 80 VATA contended for by the Appellant, which would have allowed a purchaser to claim directly from HMRC where recovery from the supplier was impossible or excessively difficult, was irreconcilable with the binding decision of the Upper Tribunal in Revenue and Customs v Earlsferry Thistle Golf Club [2014] UKUT 250 (TCC). The appeal was therefore struck out under rule 8(2)(a) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009.

Background

The Appellant appointed a construction company as principal contractor for a construction project at one of its colleges in June 2022 (para 7). The supplier charged VAT at the standard rate and accounted for it to HMRC. HMRC later confirmed, in March 2023 following the Appellant's December 2022 request for an opinion, that the supply qualified for zero rating (para 7).

On 2 May 2024 the Appellant asked HMRC to refund the VAT directly, explaining that the supplier had agreed to refund the VAT but had entered administration without doing so, leaving the Appellant with no prospect of recovery from the supplier (para 8). The Appellant relied on the Reemtsma principle recognised in Case C-35/05, Reemtsma Cigarettenfabriken GmbH v Ministero delle Finanze (para 8).

HMRC refused on 24 October 2024, and again on 11 February 2025 after further submissions, on the basis that post-Brexit there was no right to bring claims based on a failure to comply with general EU law principles, although the principle of effectiveness survived only as an interpretative tool (paras 9-10). Following a statutory review requested on 14 February 2025, HMRC's review conclusion letter of 5 September 2025 found that its decision was not appealable, because a claim under section 80 VATA could only be made by the supplier, not the purchaser (paras 11-12). The Appellant commenced the Tribunal appeal on 3 October 2025, and a hearing on jurisdiction was held on 10 September 2026 (paras 13-14).

Core dispute

It was common ground that the wording of section 80 VATA allows claims to HMRC for recovery of unduly paid VAT only by the supplier, and that section 80 VATA is the exclusive means by which HMRC will be liable to repay unduly paid VAT (para 15). It was also common ground that, by virtue of section 28(5) FA 2024, the Marleasing principle still applies to the interpretation of section 80 VATA, so that it should be interpreted as far as possible to give effect to the Reemtsma principle (para 15).

The parties agreed that if section 80 VATA could be given the conforming interpretation proposed by the Appellant, the Appellant's request would be treated as a section 80 claim and the Tribunal would have jurisdiction under section 83(1)(t) VATA; if not, the Tribunal would have no jurisdiction and the appeal would have to be struck out under rule 8(2)(a) of the Rules (paras 18-19).

The sole issue dividing the parties was therefore whether, pursuant to the Marleasing principle, section 80 VATA could be given the conforming interpretation contended for by the Appellant, namely that the Commissioners would be liable to credit the purchaser directly where it was impossible or excessively difficult for the purchaser to obtain reimbursement from the supplier (paras 17, 20). The Appellant argued this interpretation did not exceed the limits of the Marleasing principle and was not precluded by Earlsferry UT (paras 29-35). HMRC argued the interpretation exceeded the limits of the Marleasing principle, that the exclusivity of the supplier's right to claim was a cardinal feature of section 80 VATA, and that Earlsferry UT was binding authority precluding the Tribunal's jurisdiction (paras 37-40).

Court findings

The Tribunal found that it was bound by the Upper Tribunal's decision in Revenue and Customs v Earlsferry Thistle Golf Club [2014] UKUT 250 (TCC), the ratio decidendi of which precludes the conforming interpretation contended for by the Appellant (para 42).

The Tribunal held that the substantive ratio of Earlsferry UT is that, where a purchaser of a supply has paid undue VAT to the supplier and it would be impossible or excessively difficult to recover it from the supplier, the purchaser can bring an ordinary action for payment against HMRC in the courts, and this is the means by which the Reemtsma principle is given effect in the United Kingdom; it is therefore unnecessary, and not required by EU law, for the purchaser to be given a right to claim from HMRC under section 80 VATA with a right of appeal to the Tribunal (para 42(4)(b)).

The Tribunal rejected the Appellant's arguments that Earlsferry UT was not binding because it was based on an assumed or conceded point of law, that its premise was undermined by the Supreme Court's decision in Revenue and Customs v The Investment Trust Companies [2017] UKSC 29, or that it was decided per incuriam for failing to consider Marleasing authorities (para 42(5)). It also found the present case was not relevantly distinguishable from Earlsferry UT on the facts, including differences in which subsection of section 83(1) VATA was invoked, the supplier's insolvency, and the absence of a prior successful section 80 claim by the supplier (para 42(6)).

The Tribunal emphasised the importance of the doctrine of precedent and found it was bound to follow Earlsferry UT (para 42(7)). It noted that it was not for this Tribunal to express any view on whether Earlsferry UT was correctly decided, or on whether a Reemtsma claim could since 31 December 2020 be brought by a purchaser against HMRC in civil proceedings before a court (para 43).

Outcome

The Tribunal held that it had no jurisdiction to determine the appeal and that the appeal must be struck out pursuant to rule 8(2)(a) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009 (paras 1, 44). The appeal was accordingly struck out (Decision).

Major issues / areas of contention

  • Whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction under section 83(1)(t) VATA to hear an appeal brought by a purchaser of a supply seeking direct reimbursement of unduly paid VAT from HMRC.
  • Whether, by virtue of section 28(5) FA 2024, the retained Marleasing principle permitted section 80 VATA to be given a conforming interpretation allowing a claim by the purchaser where recovery from the supplier was impossible or excessively difficult, in order to give effect to the Reemtsma principle.
  • Whether the Upper Tribunal's decision in Revenue and Customs v Earlsferry Thistle Golf Club [2014] UKUT 250 (TCC) was binding on the First-tier Tribunal and precluded the conforming interpretation contended for by the Appellant.
  • Whether Earlsferry UT could be distinguished, treated as based on an assumed point of law, treated as undermined by subsequent Supreme Court authority, or treated as decided per incuriam.
  • Whether, if the conforming interpretation was not possible, the appeal had to be struck out under rule 8(2)(a) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009 for lack of jurisdiction.