This decision concerns an application by Firgrove Holdings Limited for permission to appeal out of time against HMRC's refusal to allow a VAT error correction (para 1). The Tribunal, comprising Tribunal Judge Richard Chapman KC and Ms Ann Christian, dismissed the application (paras 1, 40).
The Tribunal applied the established Martland/Katib framework for late appeals, considering the length of delay, the reasons for it, and all the circumstances including the merits of the underlying appeal (paras 19-23, 26-32).
While the Tribunal found the delay was not, by itself, sufficient to refuse permission, it ultimately dismissed the application because the substantive appeal had no real prospect of success, as the error correction claim was made outside the four-year time limit in section 80(4) VATA 1994 (paras 31-32, 37-40).
Firgrove Holdings Limited is a holding company connected to Upham Developments Limited and Turnbury Projects Limited, referred to together as the Connected Companies (para 3). Turnbury has since gone into liquidation (para 3).
Firgrove's position was that since 2017 it and the Connected Companies were entitled to an offset agreement under which credits and liabilities owed to and from HMRC would be set off against each other, referred to as the Alleged Offset Agreement, which HMRC did not accept (para 4). Firgrove made numerous requests for statements of account which it considered unsatisfactory (para 5).
In May or June 2024, HMRC began enforcement action against Firgrove, leading to a winding up petition which was later dismissed on the basis of the Alleged Offset Agreement (para 6).
By a letter dated 5 July 2024, Firgrove's accountants HJS Accountants Ltd raised the Alleged Offset Agreement and, for the first time, an issue concerning VAT adjustments, referred to as the Adjustment Issue (para 7). This concerned input tax claimed in March 2019 (£80,850, Upham invoices) and June 2019 (£58,280, Turnbury invoices), which Firgrove later reversed in its March 2020 VAT return after not paying the invoices, and which was said to have been double counted following a 2020 VAT inspection and assessment of the Connected Companies (para 8).
On 12 July 2024, HJS submitted a Form 652 error notification seeking to correct the March 2020 return (para 9). On 30 July 2024, HMRC refused the repayment by letter, stating the claim was outside the four-year time limit for correcting VAT errors; the letter was wrongly addressed and the Tribunal found Firgrove did not receive it, though it was resent to Mr Gould on 17 December 2024 (paras 10-11).
Further correspondence between HJS, Firgrove and HMRC followed in February, July 2025 and June 2026, in which HJS acknowledged the Form 652 was submitted outside the four-year time limit but said this was done to prompt HMRC to engage in dialogue about the Alleged Offset Agreement (paras 12, 15-17). Firgrove lodged its appeal, including an application to extend time, on 8 April 2025 (para 13).
The dispute was whether Firgrove should be granted permission to make a late appeal against HMRC's decision of 30 July 2024 refusing to allow the VAT error correction for the period ending March 2020 on the ground that the Form 652 notification was submitted outside the four-year time limit in section 80(4) VATA 1994 (paras 14, 25).
Firgrove argued that the delay was caused by needing to obtain documents from HMRC, that it had repeatedly but unsuccessfully tried to engage HMRC on the offset position, that no money was in fact due to HMRC because of offsets, and that HMRC should exercise discretion to allow the correction beyond four years (para 24).
HMRC argued that the delay was serious, whether measured as 222 days from the original Decision Letter or 82 days from the date it was resent, that no good reason had been given, and that the merits of the appeal were very weak because neither HMRC nor the Tribunal had discretion to extend the statutory four-year time limit for error notifications under section 80(4) VATA 1994, citing Botanical Catering Ltd v HMRC, Taylor Clarke Leisure plc v HMRC and Capital Accommodation (London) Ltd (para 25).
The Tribunal accepted that although the Decision Letter of 30 July 2024 had been sent, it had not been received by Firgrove because it was wrongly addressed, and treated 17 December 2024 (when it was resent) as the operative date (paras 10, 26-27).
Even on that later date, the appeal was 82 days late, which the Tribunal regarded as a serious and significant default, albeit slightly less serious than the three-month delay considered in Romasave (Property Services) Limited v HMRC (para 28).
The Tribunal found that Firgrove's only reason for the delay, namely needing documentation from HMRC relating to the Alleged Offset Agreement, was not a good reason, because that issue was distinct from the Adjustment Issue underlying the error correction notice, and Firgrove already had the information needed to appeal (para 29).
Applying Martland, the Tribunal found the 82-day delay would not by itself have justified refusing permission, given the context of HMRC's lack of prompt responses to Firgrove's correspondence, the absence of prejudice to HMRC, and the substantial prejudice to Firgrove if the appeal could not proceed, including the unchallenged assertion that the company would fail (paras 30-31).
However, the Tribunal found that the merits of the substantive appeal were so weak that permission should not be granted. The error notification was made more than four years after the relevant accounting period ended on 31 March 2020, and section 80(4) VATA 1994 gives no discretion to HMRC or the Tribunal to allow a late claim, following Botanical Catering Ltd v HMRC and Taylor Clarke Leisure plc v HMRC (paras 32-34, 37). Regulation 35 of the VAT Regulations 1995 did not assist, as confirmed in Capital Accommodation (London) Ltd, because HMRC's discretion as to the manner of correction does not extend to circumventing the section 80 limitation period (paras 36-37).
The Tribunal also noted that Firgrove's focus on the Alleged Offset Agreement and HMRC's alleged failures to provide information fell outside the Tribunal's jurisdiction and were not the substantive basis of the error correction notice, HMRC's decision, or the appeal (para 39).
The Tribunal dismissed Firgrove's application for permission to make a late appeal, meaning Firgrove is unable to pursue the substantive appeal further (paras 40, 41). The Tribunal expressed sympathy for Firgrove's position but found the absence of merit in the substantive case determinative (para 40).