This appeal concerned whether Groundwater Dynamics Ltd (the Appellant) was entitled to research and development tax relief and tax credits under Chapter 2 of Part 13 of CTA 2009 for expenditure incurred in its accounting periods ending 31 December 2018 and 31 December 2019 (1). The Appellant had amended its corporation tax returns in 2020 to claim R&D relief totalling £48,154.81 over the two periods, but HMRC issued closure notices on 28 October 2022 denying the claims (2).
The Tribunal heard evidence from Mr Joseph O'Meara, a founder of the Appellant, and Dr Stephen Thomas, an expert in groundwater engineering accepted by both parties as a 'competent professional' for the purposes of the Guidelines (4, 6).
The Tribunal identified two issues: whether the Appellant's activities qualified as research and development within the Research and Development (Prescribed Activities) Regulations 2004 (SI 2004/712) ('the Guidelines') (Issue 1), and, if so, the extent to which the claimed costs constituted qualifying expenditure (Issue 2) (59).
The Tribunal dismissed the appeal on both issues (113).
The Appellant was set up in 2012 by Mr O'Meara and Matthew Dale to look at renewable energy investments (24). Following a visit to Detroit airport in 2012, where they observed a drainage system using 'ECO-90' vertical infiltrators developed by a US company, Parjana, the Appellant obtained an exclusive UK licence to use the ECO-90 and began developing a business installing 'Enhanced Infiltration Systems' (EIS) (14, 25, 30).
The Appellant's business plan was to grow its business, with an element being to generate case studies and data to demonstrate to a cautious industry that EIS worked (31, 93). There was no plan identifying specific soil types or conditions in advance; installations were accepted on a commercial basis depending on suitability and price (32-33).
Between 2012 and 2017 the Appellant carried out a number of installations, including at Edgbaston Cricket Club, Gleneagles Golf Course, Royal Ascot Racecourse, Silverstone Racing Circuit, Leamington Spa and Newcastle High School for Girls, with the latter described by Mr O'Meara as the first 'engineered' EIS installation involving a more scientific design process (34-39).
In 2018 and 2019 the Appellant carried out ten further installations, including at Everton Cemetery, Wandsworth Common, Bush Estate, Cooksbridge, Stranton Cemetery, East Midlands Airport, Anstruther and Droitwich Golf Club (40). The Claims for R&D relief, prepared by Lumo Tax, calculated qualifying expenditure by applying percentage allocations of employee time, materials and subcontractor costs to named projects in each year (41-49).
HMRC accepted that the Appellant satisfied most of the statutory conditions for R&D tax relief under sections 1052 and 1053 CTA 2009, but disputed that the Appellant's activities amounted to 'research and development' within the Guidelines, specifically Condition B at s.1052(3) and Condition A at s.1053(2) (Issue 1) (59, 66).
HMRC also disputed the extent to which the Appellant's claimed costs constituted qualifying expenditure, even if Issue 1 were resolved in the Appellant's favour (Issue 2) (59).
HMRC had initially also argued the expenditure had been sub-contracted or subsidised, but this ground was dropped following Collins Construction Ltd v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2024] UKFTT 951 and Stage One Creative Services Ltd v HMRC [2024] UKFTT 1059 (3).
The central disagreement on Issue 1 was whether the Appellant's activities as a whole, aimed at having EIS accepted industry-wide, constituted a single 'project' under paragraph 19 of the Guidelines (the Appellant's case), or whether each individual installation had to be assessed separately as to whether it resolved scientific or technological uncertainty (HMRC's case) (90).
The Tribunal accepted that the Appellant's activities from 2012 had generated knowledge and data not reasonably obtainable by a competent professional, and that this represented an advance in overall knowledge or capability within paragraph 9(a) of the Guidelines (92).
However, the Tribunal found that the Appellant's overarching objective was a commercial business plan to grow its business, of which generating evidence about EIS was only an element; this did not amount to a 'project' within paragraph 19 of the Guidelines because the plan was too broad and lacked identifiable boundaries, including no clear end point as required by paragraphs 33 and 34 (94-96).
The Tribunal held that, in order to succeed, the Appellant needed to show that each installation (or sub-project) in 2018 and 2019 itself satisfied the definition of 'project' in paragraph 19, including resolving scientific or technological uncertainty not already resolved by earlier installations or by Parjana's prior work, including the 2012 Detroit airport installation and 2015 bromide test report (82-84, 95).
The Tribunal found there was no evidence, beyond a superficial description in Mr O'Meara's evidence, as to whether each 2018 and 2019 installation individually satisfied the Guidelines, because the Claims were framed as an 'all or nothing' claim without installation-by-installation evidence (88, 97).
On Issue 2, the Tribunal found that the Appellant's methodology, allocating fixed percentages of employee time, materials and subcontractor costs to named projects, assumed entitlement to claim for all activities without analysing whether each specific installation gave rise to qualifying R&D (109). The Tribunal also noted unreconciled discrepancies between installations named in the Claims and those described in evidence (110), and that Mr Glover conceded equipment costs transferred to customers were non-qualifying consumable items under s.1126A(1) (108). The Tribunal concluded the Appellant had not demonstrated it had incurred any qualifying expenditure (112).
The Tribunal dismissed the Appellant's appeal on Issue 1, finding that the Appellant's activities did not amount to a 'project' seeking to achieve an advance in science or technology within the meaning of the Guidelines (98).
The Tribunal also dismissed the appeal on Issue 2, independently of its conclusion on Issue 1, finding that the Appellant had not demonstrated it had incurred any qualifying expenditure (112-113).
The Tribunal rejected the Appellant's proposals for the parties to use best endeavours to agree quantum or for the Appellant to present alternative proposals, holding it was in the interests of justice for the case to be determined in full on the evidence before it (100-102).