Academy of taxlaw.
Register your interest

Tell us where you’re headed

We’ll confirm by email and a programme advisor will be in touch. We’ll also add you to the Academy newsletter (sent via Mailchimp) — every email includes a one-click unsubscribe.

Case summary · 12 November 2026

Gurcharn Singh Atwal v The Commissioners for HMRC

Income TaxTax AdministrationPenalties and InterestTax Court Procedure
Discovery AssessmentSection 29 TMASchedule 24 PenaltiesCareless BehaviourDeliberate BehaviourManagement ChargesRental IncomeSchedule A LossesInterest Rate Collar ProductRedress PaymentLosses Carried ForwardBurden Of ProofAuxilium TestBlind-Eye KnowledgeTime Limits For Assessment

Judgment summary

This appeal concerned discovery assessments raised by HMRC under section 29 of the Taxes Management Act 1970 against Gurcharn Singh Atwal, for the 2010-11 tax year and the 2015-16 to 2019-20 tax years, together with associated penalties under Schedule 24 of the Finance Act 2007 (paras 1, 5, 9).

The 2010-11 assessment related to management charges of £48,654 shown in the accounts of Mood Bars Ltd (MBL), which HMRC said had not been declared by the Appellant as income (paras 3, 6, 8). The assessments for 2015-16 to 2019-20 related to 'Schedule A' losses claimed to be carried forward against rental income, which HMRC disallowed to nil (paras 6, 8, 76).

The Tribunal allowed the appeal in part as regards the 2010-11 tax year, finding that the insufficiency was brought about carelessly rather than deliberately, so that the assessment was out of time and had to be vacated, with the related penalty cancelled (paras 97, 109, 114, 117). The appeal was dismissed in relation to the 2015-16 to 2019-20 tax years, with the assessments and reduced careless penalties upheld (paras 104-105, 109-113, 117).

Background

The Appellant owned and operated businesses, including a nightclub ('Koko') and public house ('Shakespeare Bar') at 45 Warwick Street, and a hotel ('TJ Hotel') and restaurant ('TJ Bar & Grill') at 45-47 Bath Street, through his company Mood Bars Ltd (MBL), formerly GSA 1986 Ltd (paras 2).

The Appellant moved his self-employment business into MBL, retained ownership of the Bath Street properties, and sold the goodwill of the self-employment business to MBL. A landlord and tenant agreement was put in place, and MBL paid rent to the Appellant. Management charges of £48,654 were shown in MBL's accounts for the year ending 30 September 2010 (paras 3).

HMRC had concerns about low self-employment profits and PAYE income declared, the fact that the management charges had not been declared in the Appellant's 2010-11 tax return, the funding of property purchases, the source of capital introduced into MBL, and rental income from residential properties (para 4).

Funding history included a 2005 purchase of 47 Bath Street for £350,000 financed by Allied Irish Bank (AIB), incorporation of MBL on 29 July 2005, a 2006 development loan of £690,000 from AIB, and a February 2008 loan of £3,710,000 from Bank of Scotland (BOS), split between the Appellant (£2,650,000) and MBL (£1,060,000), used partly to purchase 45 Warwick Street and refinance existing AIB loans (paras 19-28).

In April 2008 the Appellant was required by BOS to take out an 'interest-rate collar product' on his loan, and MBL took out an 'interest swap product' (para 29). MBL went into administration on 12 January 2012, and the Appellant was charged a 'derivative exit fee' of £422,442.00 in February 2012. The properties at 45 Warwick Street and 45-47 Bath Street were subsequently sold by administrators in 2012, giving rise to a capital gains tax loss not disputed by HMRC (paras 30-33).

In the 2014-15 tax year the Appellant received a 'redress payment' relating to the interest-rate collar product, totalling £206,646 plus interest of £68,464, and a related redress payment of £286,229.57 was paid to MBL in respect of its interest swap product (para 34).

Following an enquiry, HMRC issued decision letters in April and August 2021, and on 26 August 2021 issued discovery assessments for the 2010-11 and 2015-16 to 2019-20 tax years, totalling £44,259.09, and penalties for 2006-07 to 2019-20 totalling £57,017.16 (paras 35-38). Assessments and penalties for 2006-07 to 2009-10 and 2011-12 to 2014-15 were subsequently cancelled, leaving the sums as set out in the decision (paras 5, 38, 42).

Core dispute

The issues before the Tribunal were: whether the Appellant failed to declare the management charge received in his 2010-11 self-assessment tax return (Issue 1); whether the Appellant understated property income for 2015-16 to 2019-20, including whether the carry forward loss figures used were excessive (Issue 2); whether any loss of tax was brought about 'carelessly' or 'deliberately' by the Appellant (Issue 3); and whether the penalties had been correctly applied (Issue 4) (para 13).

The Appellant's case was that the management charges amounted to rental income assessable under 'Schedule A', that personal loans and re-mortgages funded the injection into MBL, and that losses were properly carried forward to offset against net rental income for 2015-16 to 2019-20 (para 7). HMRC's case was that the management charges had not been declared, that there were no Schedule A losses to set against them if they were found to be Schedule A income, and that the claimed losses carried forward into the later years should be disallowed to nil because there was no evidence to substantiate losses from earlier periods (paras 8, 61).

The parties also disputed the correct accounting treatment for income and expenditure relating to the BOS loans and interest-rate collar product, and whether the 2014-15 redress payment, though outside the time limit for assessment, should nonetheless be taken into account in computing losses carried forward (paras 75-79).

Court findings

On Issue 1, the Tribunal found that the management charge(s) should have been declared in the Appellant's 2010-11 tax return as separate income assessable under 'Schedule D', not as rental income, and so could not be covered by any Schedule A losses; the fees had been claimed as a trading deduction by MBL (paras 70-72).

On Issue 2, the Tribunal accepted HMRC's submission that the inability to raise an assessment for 2014-15 (being out of time) did not mean the redress payment income for that year could be ignored when computing losses carried forward; recognising that payment eradicated the carried forward losses before the first relevant assessable period, so the claimed losses could not be set against rental income in 2015-16 to 2019-20, and those assessments stood good (paras 79-81, 114).

On Issue 3, applying the tests in Auxilium Project Management v HMRC, HMRC v Tooth, CF Booth Ltd v HMRC and CPR Commercials Ltd v HMRC, the Tribunal found that, although the Appellant should have been aware of the management charge, his conduct in respect of the 2010-11 return amounted to carelessness rather than deliberate behaviour, given the extreme pressures he was under at the time from the BOS derivatives and MBL's difficulties (paras 96-97). As a result, the six-year time limit for careless behaviour applied, and the 2010-11 assessment, made in August 2021, was out of time and had to be vacated (para 97). In relation to 2015-16 to 2019-20, the Tribunal found the inaccuracies arose from the Appellant's carelessness, being a failure to take reasonable care, applying the 'prudent and reasonable taxpayer' standard from Collis v HMRC and Atherton v HMRC (paras 99, 103-104).

On Issue 4, the Tribunal found that there was no valid assessment for 2010-11 on which a penalty could arise, given the finding of carelessness and the assessment being out of time (para 109). For 2015-16 to 2019-20, the Tribunal was satisfied the penalties, calculated at 16.5% of potential lost revenue following disclosure reductions, had been correctly applied, and that HMRC's decision not to suspend the careless penalties was not 'flawed' by reference to Wednesbury principles (paras 110-113).

Outcome

The Tribunal allowed the appeal in part as regards the 2010-11 tax year, vacating the assessment of £12,455.29 (varied amount) and cancelling the related penalty, on the basis that the loss of tax arose from careless, not deliberate, behaviour and the assessment was made out of time (paras 97, 109, 114-115).

The appeal was dismissed in relation to the 2015-16 to 2019-20 tax years. The final figures were: 2015-16 tax £794.40 and penalty £131.07; 2016-17 tax £2,850.80 and penalty £470.38; 2017-18 tax £2,084.60 and penalty £343.95; 2018-19 tax £2,041.20 and penalty £336.79; 2019-20 tax £1,688.40 and penalty £278.58, giving a total tax of £9,459.40 and total penalties of £1,560.77 (para 115).

The assessments and associated penalties previously issued for 2006-07 to 2009-10 and 2011-12 to 2014-15 were cancelled, as agreed between the parties (paras 5, 38, 42, 116). Any party dissatisfied with the decision was given the right to apply for permission to appeal under Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009 within 56 days (para 118).

Major issues / areas of contention

  • Whether the Appellant failed to declare a management charge of £48,654 in his 2010-11 self-assessment tax return.
  • Whether that management charge constituted rental income assessable under 'Schedule A' (as the Appellant argued) or separate income assessable under 'Schedule D' (as HMRC and the Tribunal found).
  • Whether the Appellant understated property income for the 2015-16 to 2019-20 tax years by claiming excessive Schedule A losses carried forward.
  • Whether a 2014-15 redress payment relating to an interest-rate collar product, though outside the time limit for assessment, had to be taken into account in computing losses carried forward into later years.
  • Whether the loss of tax for 2010-11 was brought about 'carelessly' or 'deliberately' by the Appellant, affecting the applicable time limit for a discovery assessment under section 29 TMA.
  • Whether the inaccuracies for 2015-16 to 2019-20 were brought about carelessly by the Appellant.
  • Whether the Schedule 24 penalties had been correctly calculated and applied, including whether HMRC's refusal to suspend the careless penalties was flawed under Wednesbury principles.