This decision concerns HMRC's application to strike out the Appellant's appeal under Rule 8(3)(c) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009, on the basis that the grounds of appeal had already been determined in Murphy v HMRC [2025] UKUT 165 (TCC) ("Murphy UT") (1).
The appeal arose from a Closure Notice issued on 23 December 2015 under s28A TMA 1970, amending a claim for share loss relief of £1,000,028 under s574 ICTA to £8.00 (4). The Appellant also sought to have an Accelerated Payment Notice ("APN") of £398,093.20 quashed (5).
The Tribunal Judge, Jennifer Dean, held that the appeal had no reasonable prospect of success and struck it out, finding the facts materially indistinguishable from Murphy UT (108, 142-145). The Tribunal also held it had no jurisdiction over the APN, and declined to recategorise the appeal as Complex or transfer it to the Upper Tribunal (146-147).
The Claim arose from a scheme relating to Stony Heating Limited ("SHL"), considered in Price and others v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2013] UKFTT 297 ("Price FTT") and upheld in Price and others v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2015] UKUT 164 (TCC) ("Price UT") (6). The scheme was designed to create capital losses to offset against taxable income via purchase and disposal of SHL shares (6).
On 22 December 2006 the Appellant filed her Self-Assessment Return for the tax year ending 5 April 2006 ("the 2005/06 Return"), including entries at Boxes 18.8, 23.3 and 23.9 relating to a claim of £1,000,000 share loss relief under s574(1)(b) ICTA, with scheme reference number 87515797 disclosed at Box 23.5 (8-10).
On 28 September 2007 the Appellant filed her Self-Assessment Return for the tax year ending 5 April 2007 ("the 2006/07 Return"), detailing the acquisition of 100 Class B Ordinary shares in SHL for a declared cost of £1,000,120 and disposal on 19 July 2006 for £92.00, realising a capital loss of £1,000,028 (13).
HMRC opened an enquiry into the 2006/07 Return on 8 January 2008 under s9A TMA, focused on the acquisition and disposal of SHL shares (15). Following Price FTT and Price UT, HMRC issued the Closure Notice on 23 December 2015, reducing the allowable loss to £8, being the difference between the CGT base cost of £100 and the sale price of £92 (16). HMRC's statutory review upheld the Closure Notice on 30 June 2022, and the Notice of Appeal was lodged on 28 July 2022 (17-18).
HMRC applied to strike out the appeal on the basis that the same issues had already been considered and dismissed by the Upper Tribunal in Murphy UT under the 'First Share Loss Relief Issue', with no onward appeal, such that Murphy UT was binding and the appeal had no reasonable prospect of success (23).
The Appellant contended that HMRC had misunderstood or misrepresented R (oao Derry) v HMRC [2019] UKSC 19 ("Derry SC"), arguing there was no material difference between s132(1) ITA 2007 and s574(1) ICTA, that Knibbs v HMRC [2019] EWCA Civ 1719 did not affect her appeal as it concerned trade loss relief rather than share loss relief, and that Schedule 1B TMA did not apply to the Claim because there was no specific cross-reference to it in Chapter VI of Part XIII ICTA (19-22).
A further point of dispute concerned whether the 2005/06 Return was filed online or on paper, the Appellant contending it was manually completed such that the Claim was made 'in' the return within the meaning of Derry SC (24-30, 79-82).
The Appellant also sought recategorisation of the appeal to the Complex Category under Rule 23(3) and transfer to the Upper Tribunal under Rule 28 or Rule 5(3)(k)(ii), which HMRC opposed (2-3).
The Tribunal found that, on the material before it, the records supported HMRC's position that the 2006/07 return was filed on paper and the 2005/06 return was filed online, but held that this issue did not take matters further (100-102, 107).
The Tribunal held that Derry SC was distinguishable because it concerned the separate and distinguishable provisions of s132 ITA, and in Derry SC the taxpayer's claim adjusted the tax calculation and affected tax chargeable and payable, whereas in this case, as in Murphy UT, the Claim was not taken into account in the calculation of tax chargeable and payable for 2005/06 and instead gave rise to a freestanding credit (104, 108).
The Tribunal held it was bound by Murphy UT, which found that Schedule 1B TMA applied to claims for share loss relief under s574 ICTA, that the claim was to be treated as relating to 2006/07 rather than 2005/06, and that Derry SC applied only to s132 ITA share loss relief claims and not s574 ICTA claims (45, 104, 108, 119).
The Tribunal rejected the Appellant's submissions concerning alleged errors of law in Murphy FTT and Murphy UT, including arguments based on Blackburn v Keeling [2003] EWCA Civ 1221 and the correctness of De Silva, holding that this was not the correct forum to reopen the decision in Murphy UT (110-126).
The Tribunal found that the s9A TMA enquiry notice issued on 8 January 2008 and the Closure Notice issued on 23 December 2015 were validly issued (145).
The Tribunal held it had no jurisdiction to quash or consider the validity of the APN, applying Beadle v Commissioners of Revenue and Customs [2020] EWCA Civ 562 (76-77, 130, 146).
The Tribunal declined to recategorise the appeal as Complex under Rule 23(4), finding none of the criteria were met, and declined to transfer the appeal to the Upper Tribunal under Rule 28 (absent HMRC's consent) or Rule 5(3)(k)(ii) (absent any change of circumstances) (134, 136, 140).
The Tribunal held that the appeal had no reasonable prospect of success and struck it out (142).
The Tribunal found it was bound by the findings of the Upper Tribunal in Murphy UT, which disposed of the application in favour of HMRC (143).
The Tribunal confirmed that the Closure Notice was validly issued (145), that it had no jurisdiction over the APN (146), and declined to recategorise the appeal as Complex or transfer it to the Upper Tribunal (147).