Academy of taxlaw.
Register your interest

Tell us where you’re headed

We’ll confirm by email and a programme advisor will be in touch. We’ll also add you to the Academy newsletter (sent via Mailchimp) — every email includes a one-click unsubscribe.

Case summary · 11 November 2026

Jill Barlow v The Commissioners for HMRC

Tax AdministrationPenalties and InterestTax Court ProcedureCapital Gains Tax
Late AppealMartland TestLate Payment PenaltiesPermission to AppealTime to Pay ArrangementSection 280 TCGA 1992Schedule 56 Finance Act 2009Reasonable ExcuseSpecial CircumstancesProcedural FairnessEvaluative JudgmentLegitimate ExpectationThree Stage Test

Judgment summary

This is a decision of the Upper Tribunal Tax and Chancery Chamber on an application by Jill Barlow for permission to appeal a decision of the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) released on 25 September 2025 ("the Decision") (1).

The FTT had refused the Applicant's application for permission to make a late appeal against penalties for late payment of capital gains tax totalling £7,366, and had also held that, even if permission had been granted, it would have dismissed the substantive appeal (3), (9).

Judge Jonathan Cannan refused permission to appeal on paper and an oral renewal hearing took place on 9 November 2026, at which Mr Hirsch Sharma represented the Applicant and Ms Nicola Shardlow represented the Respondents (1). The Applicant advanced five grounds of appeal, all of which the Upper Tribunal rejected, refusing permission to appeal (4), (37).

Background

The Applicant realised a chargeable gain on the disposal of shares, which was included on her self-assessment return for 2012-13. The capital gains tax due to be paid on 31 January 2014 amounted to £81,314, and she made a payment of £5,095 on 10 February 2014 (5).

On 30 January 2014 she applied under section 280 Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 to pay the tax due in instalments; that application was refused by HMRC in a letter dated 10 June 2014. She then applied for time to pay, making further payments of £5,095 on 5 July 2014 and 2 September 2014. A time to pay arrangement was agreed on 25 September 2014, under which the outstanding tax was to be paid by monthly instalments of £1,500 over 51 months (5).

Late payment penalty notices were issued by HMRC on or around 18 March 2014 and 18 August 2014. The FTT found that the notices had been issued, for reasons set out at [74]-[82] of the Decision. The time for appealing was 30 days from the date the notices were given (6).

The Applicant appealed against the penalty notices on 28 June 2023, which the FTT recorded as being between 8 and 9 years out of time (7).

Core dispute

The dispute concerned whether the FTT had erred in law in refusing the Applicant permission to bring a late appeal against the two late payment penalty notices, and whether, in any event, the FTT had erred in concluding that the substantive appeal would have failed had permission been granted (3), (9).

The Applicant raised five grounds before the Upper Tribunal: that the FTT misapplied the legal test for late appeals; that the FTT failed to recognise a good explanation for the delay; that there was procedural unfairness at the FTT hearing; that justice, fairness and legitimate expectation supported granting permission for a late appeal; and that the FTT failed to take into account HMRC's waiver of penalties imposed on the Applicant's son in allegedly identical circumstances (4).

Court findings

The Upper Tribunal found that the FTT had correctly applied the three-stage test from Martland v HM Revenue & Customs [2018] UKUT 0178 (TCC), assessing the seriousness of the breach, the reasons for the delay, and all the circumstances of the case (12), (14). The FTT had found the delay of 8 to 9 years to be serious and significant, and had found no good reason for it (14).

The Upper Tribunal noted that although the FTT had applied the approach in Medpro Healthcare Ltd v HM Revenue and Customs [2025] UKUT 00255 (TCC) at the third stage, that case had subsequently been overturned on that point by the Court of Appeal, which held that particular weight should be given to the need for litigation to be conducted efficiently and for statutory time limits to be respected. The FTT's approach had therefore been more favourable to the Applicant than the approach later endorsed by the Court of Appeal (13).

On Ground 2, the Upper Tribunal held that even if HMRC had been culpable for an 8-month delay between January and September 2014, this was a small part of the overall 8-9 year delay and would not have been material. The FTT's rejection of the Applicant's explanation that an HMRC officer had told her not to appeal until the tax was paid was a finding of fact with no realistic basis for challenge (19)-(21).

On Ground 3, the Upper Tribunal found no realistic basis to criticise the FTT's conduct of the hearing, noting the FTT had gone to great lengths to ensure fairness and had permitted further written submissions and evidence after the hearing (24)-(25).

On Ground 4, applying the limited appellate jurisdiction over evaluative judgments described in Carey Street Investments Limited (in liquidation) v Brown [2024] EWCA Civ 571, the Upper Tribunal held it was not arguable that the FTT's decision was unreasonable or flawed in reasoning (28)-(29).

On Ground 5, the Upper Tribunal held there was no evidence before the FTT, or before it, as to the circumstances in which penalties against the Applicant's son had been withdrawn, and the FTT was not satisfied the circumstances were identical. In any event, HMRC's treatment of the son was not considered a relevant factor to permission for a late appeal (33)-(35).

Outcome

The Upper Tribunal refused permission to appeal on all five grounds (37).

Major issues / areas of contention

  • Whether the FTT misapplied the Martland three-stage test for permission to bring a late appeal
  • Whether the FTT failed to recognise a good explanation for an 8 to 9 year delay in appealing the penalty notices
  • Whether there was procedural unfairness in the FTT hearing, including difficulties accessing HMRC's bundle
  • Whether justice, fairness and legitimate expectation supported granting permission for a late appeal
  • Whether the FTT should have taken into account HMRC's withdrawal of penalties imposed on the Applicant's son in allegedly identical circumstances
  • The effect of the subsequent Court of Appeal reversal of Medpro Healthcare Ltd on the weight to be given to statutory time limits at the third stage of the Martland test