This decision concerns applications by Kaleidoscopes Group Limited (KG) for permission to bring late appeals against a Closure Notice issued on 09 April 2025 and a Penalty Notice issued under Schedule 55 of the Finance Act 2009 on 15 July 2025 (paras 1-3). The amounts assessed were £65,700 under the Closure Notice and £17,739 under the Penalty Notice (para 3).
HMRC opposed the applications, asserting the appeals were five months and two months late respectively, with no good reason for the delays (para 4). KG's sole director and shareholder, Peter Lacey (PL), gave evidence which the Tribunal found credible (para 2).
The underlying dispute concerned whether KG was entitled to relief under paragraph 5 of Schedule 4A of the Finance Act 2003, which, if applicable, would substitute the 15% corporate SDLT rate with individual rates, justifying the £48,300 SDLT originally paid rather than the higher amount HMRC assessed (paras 9-10).
The Tribunal applied the three-stage Martland test, found the delays serious and significant, but concluded that the reasons for delay, combined with the apparent strength of KG's substantive case, outweighed the importance of respecting statutory time limits. Permission was granted for both late appeals (paras 102-103).
KG was incorporated on 23 January 2024 to invest in assets including rental property. On 3 April 2024 it acquired a residential property in Marlow for £760,000 as the first property in a planned rental portfolio (para 13). Improvements were made and the property was marketed for rent, though the letting was ultimately unsuccessful and the property was sold (paras 14, 46).
KG's solicitors, Blazer Mills Law (BML), submitted the SDLT return and paid £48,300, applying relief under paragraph 5 of Schedule 4A of the Finance Act 2003 (paras 9, 15). HMRC opened an enquiry, requesting documents on 18 November 2024 and again on 20 January 2025, and specifically invited KG to disclose any health or personal circumstances affecting its ability to respond (paras 16-17).
HMRC assessed additional SDLT of £65,700 and issued a Closure Notice on 09 April 2025, followed by a penalty letter (paras 19-20). Correspondence in June 2025 suggested HMRC considered £58,300 the correct SDLT figure, but neither party could explain the discrepancy at the hearing (para 21).
PL had been unfairly dismissed from a senior position in August 2023 and pursued litigation under the Equality Act 2010 for around 15 months, during which he suffered significant mental health difficulties, including ADHD, Complex PTSD, Recurrent Depressive Disorder, Generalised Anxiety Disorder, Chronic Insomnia and hypothyroidism, compounded by an acrimonious divorce and the death of his sister (paras 22-23). On medical advice he took a complete break from work and engaged a family friend, informally, to assist with managing KG's affairs (paras 24-26).
PL discovered the tax dispute on 03 August 2025, immediately contacted HMRC and his tax adviser, Paul Taylor (PT) of Freestone Jacobs, and the appeals were lodged on 30 September 2025 (paras 28-30).
The core issue was whether the Tribunal should grant KG permission to bring late appeals against the Closure Notice and the Penalty Notice, applying the three-stage approach in William Martland v HMRC [2018] UKUT 0178 (TCC) (para 31).
KG accepted the delay regarding the Closure Notice was serious (five months) but argued the Penalty Notice delay (two months) was less severe, and that PL's combination of mental illness, legal dispute, divorce and bereavement constituted a 'perfect storm' amounting to a reasonable excuse that made compliance impossible rather than merely difficult (paras 32, 39-40).
HMRC argued that the delays were serious and significant, that a reasonable excuse must exist throughout the default period and prevent rather than merely hinder compliance, and that KG had not shown adequate arrangements were made to protect its appeal rights despite PL's illness (paras 51-58). HMRC also relied on the guidance in Martland as upheld by the Court of Appeal in Medpro, and on Katib and BPP, emphasising the importance of respecting statutory time limits (paras 65-68).
An ancillary dispute concerned the merits of the underlying SDLT assessment, specifically whether KG qualified for relief under paragraph 5 of Schedule 4A of the Finance Act 2003, which KG said was relatively straightforward to establish given its intention to rent the property (paras 44-46).
The Tribunal found that the delays in both appeals were serious and significant, being five months and two months respectively against a 30-day statutory time limit (para 73).
On the reasons for default, the Tribunal found that PL's mental illness, as documented in the psychiatric report, continued from at least 2021 and was exacerbated by the employment dispute, divorce and his sister's death, and that he took a break from work on medical advice while arranging informal assistance from a family friend (paras 74-80). The Tribunal concluded that the failure to protect KG's appeal rights resulted from a combination of PL's illness and the family friend's inexperience with time limits, rather than either factor alone (para 83).
The Tribunal accepted, based on PT's evidence as a Chartered Tax Adviser, that KG had a strong underlying case regarding the paragraph 5 Schedule 4A relief, and that HMRC had not identified any apparent weakness in that claim (paras 90-91).
Weighing the seriousness of the delay and the need for litigation to be conducted efficiently against the reasons for delay and the prejudice to each party, the Tribunal found that KG's evidence was sufficiently clear and compelling to mitigate the importance of strict time limit compliance in this case (paras 97, 101). The Tribunal found on balance that the strengths of KG's case outweighed the weaknesses represented by the serious and significant delays (para 102).
The Tribunal granted KG permission to bring late appeals against both the Closure Notice and the Penalty Notice (paras 102-103).
The decision records full findings of fact and reasons, with the parties notified of their right to apply for permission to appeal within 56 days pursuant to Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009 (para 104).