Academy of taxlaw.
Register your interest

Tell us where you’re headed

We’ll confirm by email and a programme advisor will be in touch. We’ll also add you to the Academy newsletter (sent via Mailchimp) — every email includes a one-click unsubscribe.

Case summary · 9 November 2026

MNS Property Holdings Ltd v The Commissioners for HMRC

VATTax AdministrationPenalties and InterestTax Court Procedure
Late Submission PenaltySchedule 24 Finance Act 2021Penalty PointsReasonable ExcusePerrin V HMRCVAT ReturnsParagraph 19Default Paper CaseRule 26Internal RestructureReliance On Another Person

Judgment summary

The Tribunal determined, on the papers, an appeal by MNS Property Holdings Ltd against two late submission penalties of £200 each, issued under the penalty points regime in Schedule 24 of the Finance Act 2021 for VAT returns for the periods ended October 2025 and January 2026 (1).

The Appellant had already accrued the maximum four penalty points for a quarterly filer before each late filing, triggering the financial penalties (5, 11). The Tribunal applied the reasonable excuse test from Perrin v HMRC [2018] UKUT 156 (TC) and Schedule 24, paragraph 19 (12, 13, 14).

The Tribunal accepted the Appellant's factual account of an internal restructure that left it without access to accounting records and software, but found insufficient evidence that the Appellant took reasonable care to avoid the failures, and dismissed the appeal (17, 24, 26).

Background

The Appellant registered for VAT in 2020 and has since filed quarterly VAT returns (2). The return for the period ended October 2025 was due by 7 December 2025 but was filed on 6 February 2026 (3). The return for the period ended January 2026 was due by 7 March 2026 but was filed on 13 March 2026 (4).

The Appellant had four penalty points, the maximum for a quarterly filer, awarded and unexpired at the time of both missed deadlines (5, 11). HMRC issued financial penalty notices of £200 on 18 December 2025 and £200 on 18 March 2026 respectively (6, 7). HMRC evidenced these facts and the Appellant did not dispute them (8).

Core dispute

The dispute concerned whether the Appellant had a reasonable excuse, within the meaning of paragraph 19 of Schedule 24 of the Finance Act 2021, for filing both VAT returns late, given that the penalty points regime was undisputedly engaged and the penalty notices were undisputedly issued and sent (15, 16).

The Appellant attributed the late filings to an internal company restructure, during which the person previously responsible for VAT records and returns was removed from that role without a proper handover, leaving the Appellant without practical access to the accounting system and information needed to file (17(1)-(3)).

HMRC argued that this amounted to reliance on another person to file the return, which paragraph 19(2)(b) of Schedule 24 excludes from being a reasonable excuse unless the Appellant took reasonable care to avoid the failure, and that the Appellant had not shown such care, had not contacted HMRC for assistance, and was aware of the consequences of late filing from previous penalty point notices (20, 21).

Court findings

Applying the Perrin framework, the Tribunal first found the facts asserted by the Appellant, namely the internal restructure, the lack of access to the accounting system and software during both periods, and the subsequent resolution of these issues (17). HMRC did not dispute these assertions and the Tribunal accepted them despite limited supporting evidence (18).

The Tribunal did not accept that the Appellant's case amounted to reliance on another person under paragraph 19(2)(b), finding instead that the facts advanced concerned an issue with company records and access to accounting software following a change of personnel, which was a process the Appellant had embarked on itself (24).

However, the Tribunal held that a company undertaking an internal restructure involving removal of staff might reasonably be expected to take steps to ensure important duties were reassigned, such as making someone else responsible for tax filings or having directors discharge the obligations themselves, and to contact HMRC if access issues arose (24). The Tribunal found insufficient evidence that the Appellant exercised reasonable care, and therefore could not conclude that the facts amounted to a reasonable excuse (24, 25).

Outcome

The appeal was dismissed (26). The two £200 late submission penalties, issued on 18 December 2025 and 18 March 2026, were upheld.

Major issues / areas of contention

  • Whether the VAT returns for the periods ended October 2025 and January 2026 were filed late, which was not disputed (15).
  • Whether the Appellant had accrued the maximum four penalty points before each late filing, triggering financial penalties, which was not disputed (15).
  • Whether an internal company restructure that removed the person responsible for VAT filings without proper handover, leaving the Appellant without access to records and software, amounted to a reasonable excuse under paragraph 19 of Schedule 24 of the Finance Act 2021.
  • Whether the Appellant's reliance on circumstances arising from the restructure constituted reliance on another person within paragraph 19(2)(b) of Schedule 24.
  • Whether the Appellant took reasonable care to avoid the failure to file on time, including whether it contacted HMRC about its difficulties.