Academy of taxlaw.
Register your interest

Tell us where you’re headed

We’ll confirm by email and a programme advisor will be in touch. We’ll also add you to the Academy newsletter (sent via Mailchimp) — every email includes a one-click unsubscribe.

Case summary · 9 November 2026

MSD Wholesale Limited v The Commissioners for HMRC

VATCustoms and ExciseTax AdministrationTax Court Procedure
Permission To AppealAdjournment ApplicationPegasus Birds TestSection 12(4)(b) Finance Act 1994AWRS RefusalExcise Duty AssessmentVAT AssessmentHolder Of GoodsBurden Of ProofCase Management DecisionBilta PrinciplesSoft LoansError Of Law

Judgment summary

This is a decision of the Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber) on an application by MSD Wholesale Limited ("MSD") for permission to appeal against a decision of the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) released on 20 February 2026 (TC/2016/04645) (1). The FTT had itself refused permission to appeal on all six grounds raised by MSD (the "FTT PTA Decision") (1). MSD then applied to the Upper Tribunal within the applicable time limit, and the application was heard on 8 October 2026 (1).

Judge Jeanette Zaman considered each of the six grounds of appeal in turn and refused permission on all of them (8, 89).

Background

MSD's underlying appeals before the FTT concerned a VAT Assessment, a First Duty Assessment, a Second Duty Assessment, a Third Duty Assessment, and a decision refusing MSD's application for approval under the Alcohol Wholesaler Registration Scheme (the "AWRS Refusal Decision") (5).

Shortly before the FTT hearing, listed for 2 to 10 December 2025, MSD's former solicitors Rainer Hughes informed HMRC on 20 October 2025 that they were no longer acting, and said they had not acted for two years, although there had been correspondence between HMRC and Rainer Hughes as recently as 31 July 2024 (11(2)). MSD instructed new solicitors, William Sturges LLP, who came on record on 18 November 2025 and received the hearing bundle (9,181 pages) on 20 November 2025; counsel's instructions were confirmed on 21 November 2025 and a skeleton argument filed on 27 November 2025 (11(4)-(5)).

MSD applied to the FTT for an adjournment at 19.08 on 26 November 2025, supported by a witness statement from Mrs Raminder Kaur Deol, a director of MSD (12, 20-21). HMRC objected on 28 November 2025 (22). The FTT refused the adjournment application, a decision set out in Appendix I to the Decision (10, 16).

Core dispute

MSD sought permission to appeal on six grounds: (1) that the FTT erred in law in refusing to grant an adjournment of the hearing; (2) that in dismissing the VAT Assessment appeal the FTT made findings based on a mistaken factual premise and failed to take account of relevant evidence; (3) that in dismissing the First Duty Assessment appeal the FTT misapplied the test in Pegasus Birds and failed to undertake the second stage of the statutory enquiry; (4) that in dismissing the Second Duty Assessment appeal the FTT again misapplied Pegasus Birds and took account of irrelevant matters; (5) that the FTT erred in concluding MSD was the holder of the goods subject to the Third Duty Assessment; and (6) that the FTT erred in concluding the AWRS Refusal Decision was one a reasonable officer could reach (5).

The test applied was whether it is arguable that the FTT made an error of law material to its decision, "arguable" meaning an argument carrying a realistic as opposed to fanciful prospect of success (4).

Court findings

On Ground 1, the Tribunal found the FTT had applied the correct principles from Bilta (UK) Ltd v Tradition Financial Services Ltd [2021] EWCA Civ 221 and the overriding objective (17). Although the FTT had erred in its description of the facts in Manchester Property Development Holdings v Kuit Steinart Levy LLP [2025] EWHC 35 (Comm), this was not arguably material (32, 44). The adjournment application as actually made was based on lack of preparation time for new advisers, not on the need to obtain further witness evidence, so it was not arguable that the FTT erred by failing to take account of alleged deficiencies in earlier preparation (26-27, 44). Permission was refused on Ground 1 (45).

On Ground 2, the FTT's conclusion that MSD had not adduced sufficient evidence of consideration paid (FTT[142]) was a finding of fact that could only be disturbed if plainly wrong (49). Although the FTT made a mistake as to chronology regarding the deregistration dates of suppliers (FTT[137]-[138]), this was not material to its conclusion, which rested on multiple other reasons including lack of audit trail, unreliable untested assertions, and limited corroborating evidence (52-53). Permission refused (54).

On Grounds 3 and 4, the Tribunal held the FTT had correctly set out and applied the Pegasus Birds test, as developed in Lithuanian Beer and DCM (Optical Holdings), and had made findings based on Officer Singh's evidence as to when he considered he had sufficient evidence to issue the assessments, which the FTT accepted as credible (59-64, 67-68). Permission refused on both grounds (64, 69).

On Ground 5, the Tribunal found no arguable misunderstanding by the FTT as to the scope of the seizure of 28 pallets, and that the FTT's conclusion relied on MSD's own acceptance that the seized alcohol belonged to it, including in a letter dated 17 July 2022 (73-77). Permission refused (78).

On Ground 6, the Tribunal held the FTT had correctly applied the test of whether HMRC's decision was one no reasonable officer could reach, and had made detailed findings as to MSD's financial position, including the so-called "soft loans", without it being arguable that the evidence compelled a different conclusion (81-87). Permission refused (88).

Outcome

The Upper Tribunal refused permission to appeal on all six grounds, concluding that none of the grounds identified an arguable error of law material to the FTT's decision (89).

Major issues / areas of contention

  • Whether the FTT erred in law in refusing MSD's application to adjourn the hearing due to late change of solicitors
  • Whether the FTT made findings on the VAT Assessment based on a mistaken factual premise regarding supplier deregistration dates
  • Whether the FTT misapplied the two-stage Pegasus Birds test in relation to the First Duty Assessment time limit under s12(4)(b) Finance Act 1994
  • Whether the FTT misapplied Pegasus Birds and took account of irrelevant matters in relation to the Second Duty Assessment
  • Whether the FTT erred in concluding MSD was the holder of the 28 pallets of goods seized and subject to the Third Duty Assessment
  • Whether the FTT erred in concluding the AWRS Refusal Decision was one a reasonable HMRC officer could reach, including treatment of alleged soft loans