Mr Haigh appealed against HMRC's refusal to accept a late notification for Enhanced Protection under reg 4 Registered Pension Schemes (Enhanced Lifetime Allowance) Regulations 2006 (SI 2006/131). The statutory deadline for notification was 5 April 2009, but Mr Haigh did not submit his notification until 17 February 2024 (24).
Before addressing the substantive appeal, the Tribunal resolved a procedural dispute about whether HMRC's application for full written findings and reasons had been made within the applicable time limit under Tribunal Rule 35(5), following a reduction in that limit from 28 to 14 days with effect from 2 March 2026 (4-17). The Tribunal found it had power under Rule 5(3)(a) to extend the time limit and did so in light of its overriding objective and the fact that the Summary Decision itself had referred to the old 28-day period (14-16).
On the substantive issue, the Tribunal applied the four-stage test from Christine Perrin v HMRC [2018] UKUT 0156 (TCC) to determine whether Mr Haigh had a reasonable excuse for his late notification (40). The Tribunal found that Mr Haigh had been unaware of the lifetime allowance or the Enhanced Protection notification requirement during the window for making a timely application, that he had not received information about the lifetime allowance from his pension administrators, and that he had taken reasonable steps by seeking financial advice at appropriate points in his life (42-45, 59).
The Tribunal concluded that the facts, viewed objectively, amounted to a reasonable excuse, noting that the Enhanced Protection notification process was transitional, novel, and affected only a limited number of people (59). The appeal was allowed (60).
Mr Haigh was an NHS dentist who retired on 28 March 2002 (19). He held an NHS pension and two defined contribution personal pension schemes, one of which crystallised around two years after retirement while the other remained uncrystallised (20).
Around his 75th birthday in January 2022, Mr Haigh was notified by the administrator of one of his personal pensions that a tax liability of £140,375 had arisen when his pension rights were tested against the lifetime allowance at age 75 (21).
On 24 July 2022, Mr Haigh submitted a late application for Fixed Protection 2012, acknowledging it was out of time and contending he had a reasonable excuse; this was refused and he appealed to the FTT (22). While preparing for that appeal, he discovered the case of Maurice Gammell v HMRC [2021] UKFTT 49 (TC), which prompted him to investigate Enhanced Protection (23).
On 17 February 2024, Mr Haigh submitted a late application for Enhanced Protection under reg 4 RPS (Enhanced Lifetime Allowance) Regs 2006 (24). On 7 June 2024, the FTT dismissed his Fixed Protection 2012 appeal for want of jurisdiction to consider the merits (25).
On 29 July 2024, HMRC informed Mr Haigh that his Enhanced Protection application did not meet the requirements of reg 4, as it was received beyond the statutory deadline of 5 April 2009 and he had not demonstrated a reasonable excuse (26, 29). HMRC upheld this view on appeal and following a statutory review (27-29). Mr Haigh notified his appeal to the Tribunal on 5 March 2025 (30).
The central issue was whether Mr Haigh had a reasonable excuse for failing to notify HMRC of his intention to rely on Enhanced Protection by the statutory deadline of 5 April 2009, as required under reg 4 RPS (Enhanced Lifetime Allowance) Regs 2006 (38). HMRC did not contest that, if a reasonable excuse existed, the notification had been made without unreasonable delay after the excuse ceased (38).
The burden of proof lay with Mr Haigh to establish, on the balance of probabilities, that he had a reasonable excuse (39). The Tribunal applied the four-stage test from Christine Perrin v HMRC [2018] UKUT 0156 (TCC) (40).
HMRC argued that Mr Haigh had not taken reasonable care to remain informed about changes to pension legislation, that the NHS and his pension administrators had no obligation to notify him individually, and that his 2024 application was effectively a retrospective attempt to obtain protection once the size of his pension fund and the reduced lifetime allowance became apparent (50-56). Mr Haigh argued that he was genuinely unaware of the lifetime allowance and the Enhanced Protection notification requirement, relying on the Gammell decision and on the test set out by Judge Berner in Adrian Platt v HMRC [2011] UKFTT 606 regarding novel and transitional requirements (47-49).
A separate procedural dispute arose over whether HMRC's application for full written findings and reasons had been made within time, given a reduction in the relevant time limit under Tribunal Rule 35(5) from 28 to 14 days (4-13).
On the procedural point, the Tribunal found that Tribunal Rule 5(3)(a) granted power to extend the time limit for complying with any rule, including Rule 35(5), and that this power had been properly exercised in accordance with the overriding objective, given that the Summary Decision itself had referred to the superseded 28-day limit (14-16). The Tribunal found no conflicting provision in any other enactment (16).
On the substantive appeal, the Tribunal found Mr Haigh to be a straightforward and reliable witness (2) and accepted his evidence as undisputed (18, 43). It found that he had not known about the lifetime allowance until notified at age 75, had received no information about it from his NHS P60s or personal pension correspondence, and had sought financial advice only at retirement and again around 2016, neither occasion touching on lifetime allowance changes (42-44).
The Tribunal agreed that HMRC had no obligation to notify individual taxpayers of legislative changes, citing Mrs Gamin Nonyane v HMRC [2017] UKFTT 11 (TC), and that it remained the taxpayer's responsibility to stay informed (51). It also agreed that Gammell was not binding and that its facts differed from Mr Haigh's situation (55).
However, the Tribunal rejected HMRC's argument that Mr Haigh's application was impermissibly retrospective, noting that he had not known the size of his pension funds or anticipated changes to the lifetime allowance at the relevant time, and had simply been unaware of any notification requirement (57). Applying the Platt test, the Tribunal found that the Enhanced Protection notification process was transitional, novel, and affected only a limited number of people, and that it was reasonable for a retired dentist in Mr Haigh's position not to have become aware of the statutory deadline (59).
The Tribunal decided that the appeal should be ALLOWED (60). The decision records full findings of fact and reasons, with a right for either party to apply for permission to appeal under Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009, within 56 days of the decision being sent (61).