Academy of taxlaw.
Register your interest

Tell us where you’re headed

We’ll confirm by email and a programme advisor will be in touch. We’ll also add you to the Academy newsletter (sent via Mailchimp) — every email includes a one-click unsubscribe.

Case summary · 6 November 2026

Ramin Hoodeh v The Commissioners for HMRC

Tax AdministrationTax Court Procedure
Rule 10(1)(b)Unreasonable ConductClosure NoticesDistinctive CareCosts ApplicationComplaint FindingsSelf-AssessmentEmployment ExpensesRepayment of TaxTier 2 Complaint InvestigationDuty of CandourTribunal DirectionsLitigant in Person

Judgment summary

The Appellant applied under Rule 10(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009 for an order for costs, contending that HMRC had acted unreasonably in defending or conducting proceedings relating to his application for closure notices (1). HMRC opposed the application, arguing that the conduct complained of related to the underlying enquiry rather than to the proceedings before the Tribunal (2).

The Tribunal, applying Distinctive Care Ltd v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2019] EWCA Civ 1010 and related authorities, held that the focus of Rule 10 is the conduct of litigation rather than the quality of the underlying decision-making (25, 55). The Tribunal found that HMRC's pre-proceedings conduct, including delays and communication failures accepted during HMRC's complaints process, formed context but did not of itself establish unreasonable conduct in the proceedings (56-58).

The Tribunal considered HMRC's email of 4 February 2026, in which HMRC informed the Tribunal that closure notices had been issued and that it regarded the matter as settled, and found this to be procedurally imperfect but not objectively unreasonable, given that the substantive relief sought had already been provided (60-66). The Tribunal rejected the allegation that HMRC had misled the Tribunal regarding the repayment position (72-79). The application for costs was dismissed (84).

Background

On 20 August 2025, the Appellant submitted self-assessment tax returns for 2021/22 to 2024/25 claiming deductions for employment expenses and consequential repayments of tax (4). HMRC opened enquiries on 16 September 2025 and stated that no repayments would be made until the enquiries concluded (5).

The Appellant made repeated contact with HMRC regarding progress and repayment, recorded on 17 September, 7 November, 10 November, 17 November, 11 December and 22 December 2025 (6). On 10 November 2025, HMRC indicated closure notices would be issued within seven to ten working days, but this did not occur, leading to complaints which were later upheld in part (7-8).

On 31 December 2025, the Appellant complained to HMRC and applied to the Tribunal for a direction requiring closure notices (9). HMRC issued closure notices for 2021/22 to 2023/24 on 14 January 2026 and for 2024/25 on 29 January 2026 (10, 12). A repayment was generated within HMRC's systems on 30 January 2026 but failed processing and security checks (13).

On 4 February 2026, HMRC informed the Tribunal and the Appellant that closure notices had been issued, a repayment of £1,409.37 generated, and that it considered the matter settled, stating it would not issue further pleadings (14). The Appellant responded the same day that he did not regard the matter as settled as he had not received the repayment (15). The repayment of £1,411.35 was eventually issued on 17 February 2026 (18).

Core dispute

The dispute was whether HMRC had acted unreasonably in bringing, defending or conducting the proceedings for the purposes of Rule 10(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009 (1-2).

The Appellant relied on HMRC's unilateral assertion that the proceedings were settled, HMRC's failure to provide a statement of reasons following the Tribunal's direction of 15 January 2026, an allegation that HMRC misled the Tribunal regarding the repayment, procedural deficiencies including an incomplete hearing bundle and a late skeleton argument, and the wider history of delay and communication failures identified during HMRC's complaints process (31-35, 44-51).

HMRC contended that none of its conduct, before or during the proceedings, crossed the threshold of unreasonable conduct required by Rule 10(1)(b), and that the substantive relief sought (closure notices) had already been provided by the time it responded to the proceedings (37-41).

Court findings

The Tribunal held that the issue was not whether HMRC's handling of the enquiries met acceptable standards, but whether HMRC acted unreasonably in bringing, defending or conducting the proceedings (54). Pre-proceedings conduct, including delays and complaint findings, was taken into account as context but was not itself capable of justifying a costs order under Rule 10(1)(b) (56-58).

The Tribunal found HMRC's approach to the 4 February 2026 email procedurally imperfect, since proceedings remained extant unless withdrawn or disposed of by the Tribunal, but concluded that HMRC's position, that no substantive issue remained given the issue of closure notices, was reasonably open to it (60-64). HMRC's failure to provide a statement of reasons under the 15 January 2026 direction was found to stem from its understanding of the procedural effect of the closure notices rather than disregard of the Tribunal's authority, and did not cross the Rule 10(1)(b) threshold (65-66).

The Tribunal rejected the allegation that HMRC misled the Tribunal regarding the repayment, noting the distinction between generation and eventual payment of the repayment, and relying on findings of HMRC's Tier 2 complaint investigation that the information provided by the litigation officer was accurate on the information available at the time (72-79). Omissions in the hearing bundle and a late skeleton argument were found to result from oversight, promptly corrected, and did not amount to unreasonable conduct (69-70).

Outcome

The Tribunal concluded that it was not satisfied that HMRC acted unreasonably in bringing, defending or conducting the proceedings within the meaning of Rule 10(1)(b) (80). The application for costs was dismissed, and it was unnecessary to consider questions of causation, recoverability or quantum (81, 84).

Major issues / areas of contention

  • Whether HMRC acted unreasonably in bringing, defending or conducting the proceedings under Rule 10(1)(b).
  • Whether pre-proceedings conduct, including delays and complaint findings, was relevant to assessing unreasonable conduct in the proceedings.
  • Whether HMRC's email of 4 February 2026 asserting the matter was settled amounted to unreasonable conduct.
  • Whether HMRC's failure to provide a statement of reasons following the Tribunal's direction of 15 January 2026 was unreasonable.
  • Whether HMRC misled the Tribunal regarding the generation and payment of the repayment.
  • Whether procedural deficiencies in the costs proceedings, including an incomplete hearing bundle and late skeleton argument, constituted unreasonable conduct.