Rukayat Lawal appealed against a joint customs and excise civil evasion penalty (CEP) assessed by HMRC on 9 January 2025, totalling £15,102, comprising a customs duty penalty of £4,516 and an excise duty penalty of £10,586 (paragraph 1).
HMRC alleged that Ms Lawal dishonestly attempted to evade customs duty, import VAT and excise duty on 5 July 2024 at Manchester Airport, having arrived from Nigeria via Doha carrying 59,980 Benson & Hedges cigarettes, far exceeding the travellers' allowance of 200 cigarettes (paragraphs 2, 13, 19, 22).
The Tribunal, comprising Judge Ashley Greenbank and Susan Stott, heard evidence from Ms Lawal, Officer Sonny Bailey (the Border Force officer who stopped her) and Officer Natasha Sultman (the HMRC officer who conducted the penalty investigation) (paragraph 15).
The Tribunal preferred Officer Bailey's evidence over Ms Lawal's account on key factual disputes, including who initiated contact and what was said during questioning (paragraphs 31, 34).
The Tribunal found that Ms Lawal knew she was carrying cigarettes far in excess of the allowance, was aware of the existence of customs allowances, and entered the green channel without intending to make a voluntary declaration (paragraphs 36, 44, 47).
Applying the test for dishonesty set out in Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd t/a Crockfords [2017] UKSC 67, the Tribunal found that Ms Lawal's conduct was dishonest by the objective standards of ordinary decent people (paragraphs 45-49).
The Tribunal upheld HMRC's reduction of the penalty by 60% (30% for disclosure and 30% for cooperation), out of a possible maximum reduction of 80% under HMRC Notices 160 and 300, and declined to allow any further mitigation, noting that insufficiency of funds could not be taken into account by statute (paragraphs 52, 55, 56).
The appeal was dismissed and the penalty of £15,102 was confirmed (paragraph 57).
On 5 July 2024, Ms Lawal arrived at Manchester Airport from Nigeria via Doha carrying three large suitcases (paragraph 19). She entered the green channel, where Officer Bailey approached her and identified himself as a Border Force officer (paragraph 20).
During questioning, Ms Lawal stated she had been in Nigeria for three days visiting her sick father, confirmed the suitcases belonged to her but had been packed by a friend, said the suitcases contained some cigarettes and fish, and denied being aware of her customs allowances (paragraph 21).
Officer Bailey searched the luggage and found 59,980 Benson & Hedges cigarettes, which he seized. Ms Lawal signed form BOR156A and Officer Bailey's notebook recording the interview. She did not take any action to recover the cigarettes (paragraphs 22-23).
By letter dated 6 November 2024, HMRC advised Ms Lawal they were inquiring into her customs duty, import VAT and excise duty affairs for the period between 5 July 2023 and 6 November 2024 (paragraph 24). Correspondence followed in which Ms Lawal provided information, including that she had taken seven international trips in that period (paragraph 25).
By letter dated 9 January 2025, HMRC advised Ms Lawal that they would charge a CEP under section 25 Finance Act 2003 and section 8 Finance Act 1994, on the grounds she had dishonestly sought to evade the duties, allowing a 60% reduction in recognition of her disclosure and cooperation (paragraph 26). The penalties were confirmed following a review (paragraph 27).
The issues before the Tribunal were: first, whether Ms Lawal engaged in conduct for the purpose of evading duty under section 8(1)(a) FA 1994 and section 25(1)(a) FA 2003; second, if so, whether that conduct involved dishonesty under section 8(1)(b) FA 1994 and section 25(1)(b) FA 2003; and third, if so, whether any penalty should be reduced beyond the mitigation already allowed by HMRC under section 8(4)(a) FA 1994 and section 29(1)(a) FA 2003 (paragraph 39).
Ms Lawal's case was that she did not act dishonestly, maintaining she had intended to approach a Border Force officer of her own accord to disclose the cigarettes. She also relied on her cooperation during HMRC's investigation and her personal financial circumstances (paragraph 3).
The Tribunal preferred Officer Bailey's consistent, contemporaneous account over Ms Lawal's evidence, finding that Ms Lawal entered the green channel, that Officer Bailey approached her, and that he initiated the conversation (paragraphs 29-31).
The Tribunal found that when questioned, Ms Lawal declared she was carrying some cigarettes but did not indicate the actual quantity (paragraph 34). The Tribunal did not find credible her claim that she was unaware of customs allowances, noting she had made five international trips (excluding the trip in question) between July 2023 and July 2024, including another trip to Nigeria, and could not be described as an inexperienced traveller (paragraphs 35-36).
The Tribunal found that Ms Lawal was aware of the existence of the allowances and knew she was carrying cigarettes in excess of them when she entered the green channel (paragraph 36). It did not accept her explanation that the cigarettes were intended as a souvenir for a friend's 70th birthday party, given the quantity involved (approximately 300 times the allowance, with an estimated retail value of over £45,000) (paragraph 38).
Applying the principle from Jones & Jones v HMRC [2011] EWCA Civ 824, the Tribunal found it was not material in this case, concluding instead that Ms Lawal's conduct in knowingly importing excess cigarettes through the green channel, without intending a voluntary declaration, constituted conduct for the purpose of evading excise duty, import VAT and customs duty under section 8(1)(a) FA 1994 and section 25(1)(a) FA 2003 (paragraphs 42-44).
Applying the test for dishonesty in Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd t/a Crockfords [2017] UKSC 67, the Tribunal found that Ms Lawal knew her conduct involved evasion of duty, and that applying the objective standards of ordinary decent people, her conduct was dishonest (paragraphs 45-49).
On mitigation, the Tribunal agreed with Officer Sultman's reasons for not applying the maximum available reduction of 80%, including that Ms Lawal's explanation for the cigarettes was not accepted, her assertion of innocent mistake was not accepted, and her account had not been entirely truthful. The Tribunal confirmed that a 60% reduction was appropriate, and noted it could not take into account the insufficiency of funds available to Ms Lawal under section 8(5)(a) FA 1994 and section 29(3)(a) FA 2003 (paragraphs 53-56).
The Tribunal dismissed the appeal and confirmed the penalty of £15,102 (paragraph 57).