This case concerns a reference for a preliminary ruling from the Högsta förvaltningsdomstolen (Supreme Administrative Court, Sweden) on the interpretation of Article 63 TFEU in relation to withholding tax levied on dividends paid to a loss-making non-resident company (1).
Société Générale SA, a French company belonging to a group subject to consolidated taxation in France, received dividends from Swedish companies in 2012, on which Swedish withholding tax was levied at source (15, 16). It sought a refund, arguing the taxation restricted free movement of capital since it was loss-making and a comparable Swedish company would not have been taxed in the same way (17).
The Swedish Tax Authority refused the refund because the loss relied upon had not been calculated according to Swedish tax rules (18). This refusal was upheld by the Förvaltningsrätten i Falun (Administrative Court, Falun), which found that Société Générale had not demonstrated, by calculating the result of the tax group in accordance with Swedish tax rules, that it was comparable to a loss-making Swedish company (19).
The Supreme Administrative Court referred three questions to the Court of Justice, asking essentially whether Article 63 TFEU permits a source state to require a non-resident company to recalculate its taxable profit or loss according to the source state's rules, and whether this applies where the company is part of a consolidated tax group, including where the source state itself has no consolidated taxation regime but only intra-group transfer rules (26).
The Court answered that Article 63 TFEU precludes the practice of requiring a non-resident company, belonging to a consolidated tax group in its state of residence, to prove its loss-making situation by systematically recalculating its taxable results according to the rules of the state of source (85).
The dispute arose from the Law (1970:624) on the Tax on Dividends ('the Law on the Tax on Dividends'), under which dividends on shares in Swedish companies are subject to a 30% withholding tax, with a right to refund in certain situations under Paragraph 27 of that law (6-10).
Following the Court's judgment in Sofina and Others (C-575/17), Sweden introduced Paragraphs 28 to 28n of the Law on the Tax on Dividends, in force from 1 January 2020, allowing a non-resident EU company to obtain deferral of payment of dividend tax where it records a loss calculated in accordance with Swedish tax rules; if the company belongs to a consolidated group in its home state, the deferral is calculated by reference to the whole group (11, 36).
Although this legislation was not applicable ratione temporis to the 2012 dividends at issue, the tax authority required Société Générale to provide the evidence referred to in that law in order to obtain a refund, meaning it had to recalculate its own and its group's results according to Swedish tax rules (37).
The referring court noted that Sweden has no rules on consolidated taxation of groups, though Chapter 35 of the Law (1999:1229) on Income Tax permits intra-group transfers allowing profit and loss compensation under certain conditions (14, 25).
The central question was whether it is compatible with Article 63 TFEU for the Member State taxing dividends at source to require a non-resident company, claiming to be in a situation objectively comparable to a resident loss-making company, to prove this by recalculating its taxable profit or loss according to the source state's own tax rules (26, Question 1).
A further question was whether, where the non-resident company is subject to consolidated taxation in its home state, the source state may require the profit or loss of the whole tax group to be taken into account using the source state's rules, and whether the answer changes if the source state has no consolidated taxation regime but does have intra-group transfer rules permitting profit and loss compensation (26, Questions 2 and 3).
The Court found that requiring non-resident companies to recalculate their taxable results under Swedish rules, as an additional condition for deferral or refund, represents an administrative burden borne only by non-resident companies, liable to impede cross-border transactions and constituting a tax disadvantage, and therefore a restriction on free movement of capital under Article 63(1) TFEU (39, 40).
On comparability, the Court held that since Sweden taxes dividends paid to both resident and non-resident companies, their situations become objectively comparable as regards ability to pay, where taxable results are determined under the rules of each company's own state of residence (44-47, 52). Any recalculation under a different state's rules pertains to a hypothetical situation (52). The differences resulting from the absence of harmonisation across Member States' tax rules do not undermine this comparability (54, 55).
The Court rejected justification based on the balanced allocation of powers of taxation and fiscal cohesion, reaffirming the approach taken in Sofina and Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) (68, 69). As to prevention of tax evasion and avoidance, the Court accepted this as a legitimate aim capable of justifying a restriction in principle (71), and acknowledged that Member States may require taxpayers to provide necessary proof (72, 73). However, a systematic requirement to recalculate results under the source state's rules, without allowing other evidence that clearly and precisely demonstrates the conditions are met, is based on a generalised suspicion of fraud rather than specific evidence of an artificial arrangement, and goes beyond what is necessary (75, 76, 78).
The Court held that this conclusion applies with even greater force where a non-resident company belongs to a group subject to consolidated taxation in its home state, and that it makes no difference that the source state lacks consolidated taxation but instead has intra-group transfer rules (79, 80). The Court distinguished the case from Marks & Spencer, noting that the present case does not concern deduction of foreign losses but the timing of the source state's right to tax income generated in its territory (82, 83).
The Court ruled that Article 63 TFEU must be interpreted as precluding the practice of a Member State's tax authority of requiring a non-resident company, which belongs to a group of companies subject to consolidated taxation in its Member State of residence and which relies on its loss-making situation to obtain a refund of withholding tax on dividends received from a company resident in the first Member State, to prove that loss-making situation by systematically recalculating its taxable results in accordance with the rules applied by the first Member State for taxing resident companies (85, operative part).
Costs were left to be determined by the referring court, as the proceedings formed a step in the action pending before it (86).