This is HMRC's appeal against a First-tier Tribunal (FTT) decision in Ingliston Driving Experiences Ltd v HMRC [2025] UKFTT 564 (TC) (1). The case concerns whether supplies of supercar driving experiences qualified for the temporary reduced rate of VAT introduced during the Covid-19 pandemic under section 29A of, and Group 16 of Schedule 7A to, the Value Added Tax Act 1994 (2).
The FTT had held that Ingliston's event days were supplies of a right of admission to 'similar cultural events and facilities' within Group 16, Item 1, and therefore qualified for the reduced rate (3). HMRC appealed on five grounds (3), (42).
The amount in dispute totalled £44,903.48, comprising denial of a repayment claim of £13,109.20 and an assessment (reduced on review) of £31,794.28 (4). A separate disallowance of input tax of £2,091.47 was not disputed by Ingliston (4).
The Upper Tribunal (Judge Swami Raghavan and Judge Kevin Poole) allowed HMRC's appeal, set aside the FTT Decision, and remade it by dismissing Ingliston's appeal, upholding HMRC's assessment and denial of the repayment claim (109).
Group 16 of Schedule 7A VATA 1994, headed 'Shows and certain other attractions', was a temporary provision having effect from 15 July 2020 to 31 March 2022, with a reduced rate of 5% until 30 September 2021 and 12.5% thereafter (8). The supplies in issue were made during the initial 5% period (8). Item 1 covered supplies of a right of admission to shows, theatres, circuses, fairs, amusement parks, concerts, museums, zoos, cinemas and exhibitions 'and similar cultural events and facilities' (2), (6), materially mirroring Item 7 of Annex III to the Principal VAT Directive (5), (7).
Ingliston operated 'event days' at off-road venues at which customers drove, or were driven in, high-performance 'supercars' (2), (20). It ran approximately five or six event days each month from three venues: a rally and go-kart track, a former race circuit and a current race circuit, using one venue at a time (20), (24). It owned a fleet of 18 vehicles, 16 two-seaters and two BMW M3 four-seaters, with an average of about 12 vehicles on track at once (25).
Customers typically purchased vouchers, selected a venue, vehicle and optional extras, and received a ticket entitling them to participate (22). On a typical event day approximately 200 customers held pre-booked tickets, with substantial additional on-the-day sales (23), (28). Customers could drive themselves (60% to two-thirds of customers) or be driven by a professional driver, always accompanied by an instructor (26). Paying customers were admitted to a fenced pitlane area, crossed in a few seconds, before accessing vehicles; a surrounding 'paddock' area, open to the public without a ticket, contained catering facilities (29). The minimum driving age was normally 12, with no upper age limit (30).
The FTT found Mr Hayes's evidence 'straightforward, credible and reliable' (19) and that the core of Ingliston's business was to provide enjoyment rather than driving tuition (21).
The dispute was whether Ingliston's supplies constituted a 'right of admission' to 'shows, theatres, circuses, fairs, amusement parks, concerts, museums, zoos, cinemas and exhibitions and similar cultural events and facilities' within Item 1 of Group 16, Schedule 7A VATA 1994, so as to qualify for the temporary reduced rate (2), (6).
HMRC advanced five grounds of appeal: (1) that the FTT misconstrued 'right of admission' and failed to distinguish it from a supply that was 'considerably more' than admission; (2) that the FTT misunderstood 'collective enjoyment'; (3) that the FTT wrongly took account of enjoyment by non-paying spectators; (4) that the FTT erred in its treatment of customer numbers and failed to give weight to the limited number enjoying the attraction simultaneously; and (5) that the FTT adopted an incorrect approach to similarity with the listed attractions (42).
It was common ground that Ingliston's event days were not themselves a fair, amusement park or any other named attraction, so the case turned on the residual words 'similar cultural events and facilities' (49), (50).
On Ground 5, the Upper Tribunal rejected HMRC's submission that, beyond identifying the characteristics of the statutory category, a second stage was required establishing similarity to a specific named attraction. The statutory language required only that an unlisted event or facility be sufficiently similar to the category represented by the list (45)-(54). Ground 5 was dismissed (57).
On collective enjoyment (central to Grounds 1 to 4), the Tribunal held that the phrase 'the right collectively to enjoy' in Erotic Center v Belgian State (Case C-3/09) does not require collective amusement or shared social experience, but concerns whether paying customers are admitted to receive the benefit of the same underlying event or facility made available in common, as opposed to a service supplied individually for private consumption (69)-(75).
The FTT had wrongly treated the physical presence of several cars, visibility between occupants, simulated races, and the absence of solitude as establishing collective enjoyment; this conflated a shared physical setting with collective enjoyment of a common event or facility (94)-(103). Ground 2 was made out (103), and the same error affected the FTT's characterisation of the supply as admission under Ground 1, which was also made out (104).
On Ground 3 (spectators), the Tribunal held that the FTT's reliance on spectators enhancing participants' enjoyment reflected the same mistaken understanding of collective enjoyment, rather than a separate error, but Ground 3 was nonetheless made out (76)-(80).
On Ground 4 (numbers), the Tribunal rejected HMRC's case that the listed attractions required relatively large numbers of simultaneous customers or strict simultaneity, holding that neither Group 16 nor Erotic Center imposed any such threshold. Ground 4 was not made out (81)-(86).
The Tribunal found that passive enjoyment and limited staff interaction are not defining characteristics of Group 16, nor do customer choice or active participation by themselves exclude a supply from the provision (88)-(90), (105). However, each Ingliston customer purchased a separately selected driving experience, choosing a vehicle, add-ons, and whether to drive or be driven, and this defined the service supplied; the event day brought these separately purchased experiences together but did not make them a common event or facility (98)-(103), (107).
The Upper Tribunal held that the errors established under Grounds 1 and 2 were material and required the FTT Decision to be set aside (106). As no further findings of primary fact were needed, the Tribunal remade the decision on the FTT's existing findings (106).
Applying the correct legal approach, the Tribunal concluded that Ingliston supplied recreational driving experiences rather than rights of admission to events or facilities within Group 16, and that the supplies did not qualify for the temporary reduced rate (107)-(108).
HMRC's appeal was allowed. The Upper Tribunal set aside the FTT Decision and remade it by dismissing Ingliston's appeal. HMRC's assessment for VAT period 10/20 and its denial of the repayment claim were upheld (109).