United Worldwide Travel Ltd (UWT), a money services business and travel agency, appealed against a penalty imposed by HMRC for failing to comply with the Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017 (the MLR). HMRC had originally imposed a penalty of £4,936, which was varied on review to £4,798 (paragraph 1, paragraph 21).
The Tribunal, comprising Tribunal Judge Rachel Gauke and Julian Sims, heard evidence from Mr Giama, UWT's director, and from Officer Sheikhol, the HMRC officer who issued the penalty (paragraph 9). The Tribunal examined HMRC's calculation of the penalty under HMRC's Penalties Framework, which uses a two-component approach (Component A and Component B) (paragraph 16 to paragraph 17).
The Tribunal found that HMRC had incorrectly calculated Component A by using the gross commission on non-compliant transactions rather than the 40% net commission actually retained by UWT after payment to its platform provider, Amal Express (paragraph 35 to paragraph 39). Correcting this error, the Tribunal recalculated the penalty at £1,919.58 (paragraph 39 to paragraph 40).
The Tribunal otherwise found that HMRC had correctly applied the Penalties Framework and properly considered the factors required under Regulation 83(1) of the MLR, including UWT's financial strength, level of co-operation, and history of non-compliance (paragraph 55 to paragraph 56). The appeal was allowed in part, with the penalty reduced to £1,919.58 (paragraph 61).
UWT has been registered with HMRC for money laundering supervision purposes since 2006 (paragraph 11). In 2014, UWT received a warning letter after HMRC discovered breaches of the MLR relating to failures to make enquiries about the source of funds, missing identity documents, and insufficient evidence of customer due diligence (paragraph 11).
Between November 2023 and July 2024, HMRC reviewed UWT's compliance with the MLR, including visits to UWT's premises, meetings with Mr Giama, and review of records (paragraph 12). HMRC reviewed transactions between 14 November 2022 and 13 November 2023, during which UWT carried out 748 transactions totalling approximately £400,000 (paragraph 13).
HMRC identified breaches in 16 out of 110 transactions considered during the investigation, relating to failures to apply enhanced customer due diligence and failures to comply with UWT's own anti-money laundering procedures (paragraph 14 to paragraph 15). Some breaches involved transactions with high-risk third countries including South Sudan, Yemen and Uganda (paragraph 14, paragraph 26).
On 8 January 2025, Officer Sheikhol wrote to Mr Giama indicating HMRC's intention to impose a penalty, calculated according to HMRC's Penalties Framework (paragraph 16). The penalty notice was issued on 12 March 2025 for £4,936, following adjustments for cancelled transactions (paragraph 19). On review, the amount was reduced to £4,798.95 to correct an error relating to transactions conducted in US dollars (paragraph 21). Mr Giama appealed to the Tribunal on 23 July 2025 (paragraph 22).
The sole ground of appeal was that the penalty amount was not appropriate or proportionate given UWT's profit, with UWT disputing the profit figures used by HMRC (paragraph 23). Mr Giama made additional submissions that the non-compliance was limited in scope, that UWT had co-operated fully with HMRC, that no criminal activity had been alleged, that the penalty was disproportionate given the small scale of the business, and that UWT had since made compliance improvements (paragraph 24).
The parties agreed the penalty was effective and dissuasive; the dispute centred on whether it was proportionate (paragraph 32). A further issue arose during the hearing concerning the correct method for calculating Component A of the penalty, specifically whether this should reflect gross commission on non-compliant transactions or only the net commission retained by UWT after payment to Amal Express (paragraph 35 to paragraph 38).
The Tribunal found that HMRC had incorrectly calculated Component A by using the gross commission figure rather than the 40% net commission actually retained by UWT, since the 60% paid to Amal Express was not a cost in the nature of a bank charge but represented Amal Express's own entitlement under a commission-sharing arrangement (paragraph 38 to paragraph 39). Using the corrected figures, the Tribunal found the penalty should have been £1,919.58 (paragraph 39 to paragraph 40).
The Tribunal found that HMRC's officer had made an error in identifying UWT's gross profit for the year ending 28 February 2023, mistakenly using the retained earnings figure of £46,481 rather than the correct gross profit figure of £52,635, with an operating profit of £5,149 (paragraph 47 to paragraph 49). However, the Tribunal found this error made no practical difference, since the correct gross profit figure was higher than the figure mistakenly used, and the penalty remained well below three years' worth of gross profits under the Penalties Framework (paragraph 50 to paragraph 52).
The Tribunal upheld HMRC's assessment of the penalty as higher tier, finding that 16 out of 110 transactions being non-compliant amounted to a pattern of multiple breaches rather than an isolated incident, and that similar breaches had been identified in 2014 without being rectified (paragraph 53 to paragraph 54). The Tribunal found that HMRC had properly considered all relevant factors under Regulation 83(1) (paragraph 55).
The Tribunal rejected Mr Giama's submissions regarding limited scope of non-compliance, absence of criminal allegations, and subsequent improvements as grounds for further reducing the penalty, though it noted UWT had already received credit for co-operation through the maximum behavioural reduction under the Penalties Framework (paragraph 59).
The Tribunal allowed the appeal in part, reducing the penalty from £4,798.95 (as varied on review) to £1,919.58, to reflect the correct calculation of Component A (paragraph 2, paragraph 61). In all other respects, the Tribunal confirmed HMRC's approach to calculating and imposing the penalty.