Academy of taxlaw.
Register your interest

Tell us where you’re headed

We’ll confirm by email and a programme advisor will be in touch. We’ll also add you to the Academy newsletter (sent via Mailchimp) — every email includes a one-click unsubscribe.

Case summary · 26 October 2026

WCF Limited v The Commissioners for HMRC

VATTax AdministrationPenalties and InterestTax Court Procedure
Late Payment PenaltySchedule 26 FA 2021Reasonable ExcuseSpecial CircumstancesVAT CreditRunning VAT AccountSection 25 VATA 1994Offset of VAT CreditRule 33 Hearing in AbsenceRule 38 Set AsideTradecorpDCM Optical HoldingsRepayment ClaimChristine Perrin Test

Judgment summary

WCF Limited appealed against two late payment penalties totalling £511.64, charged under Schedule 26 to the Finance Act 2021, relating to the VAT period ended 01/24 (paragraph 2). HMRC did not attend the hearing, and the Tribunal proceeded in HMRC's absence under Rule 33 of the Tribunal Procedure Rules, finding it was in the interests of justice to do so (paragraphs 4 to 16).

The Tribunal found that WCF had filed its VAT returns for periods 11/23 and 01/24 on time, and believed it was entitled to offset a repayment of £4,445.16 claimed for period 11/23 against the £5,318.67 owed for period 01/24 (paragraph 21, 27). HMRC had failed to process WCF's 11/23 VAT return until March 2026, over two years after receipt, due to unexplained administrative errors (paragraph 27(6)).

Applying section 25 VATA 1994 and the principles in R (Tradecorp) v Customs and Excise Commissioners and DCM (Optical Holdings) Limited v HMRC, the Tribunal held that WCF was not entitled to offset the repayment claim until it had been admitted or established by HMRC, which only occurred in March 2026. Accordingly, the VAT was found to have been paid late and the penalties had been correctly charged (paragraphs 32 to 37).

However, applying the guidance in Christine Perrin v HMRC, the Tribunal found that WCF had a reasonable excuse for the late payment, based on its mistaken but reasonable belief in its entitlement to offset, reinforced by HMRC's past prompt processing of repayments and its failure to verify or chase the claim (paragraphs 42 to 44). The reasonable excuse was found to continue until HMRC admitted the 11/23 repayment claim in March 2026 (paragraph 50). The appeal was therefore allowed and the penalties set aside (paragraph 51).

The Tribunal also indicated, obiter, that had it been necessary, it would have found special circumstances existed and would have reduced the penalties to zero, given the almost two-year period during which the 4% annual penalty rate was applied due to HMRC's failure to process the return (paragraphs 52 to 54). A further ground concerning whether the second penalty was issued outside the two-year time limit was not addressed, as it was unnecessary given the outcome (paragraph 55).

Following the hearing, HMRC applied, in effect, to set aside the decision under Rule 38, citing a road traffic accident that prevented its representative from attending. Judge Smith, deciding on the papers, refused the application, finding it was not in the interests of justice to set aside the decision, noting HMRC's substantial written submissions, its large legal resources, the limited prejudice caused, and that the outcome was not finely balanced.

Background

WCF Limited was established decades ago, originally known as West Cumberland Farmers, and is one of the largest employers in its home region with an annual turnover of around £200M. It consists of several divisions, some with their own VAT registrations. This appeal concerned the division known as 'Herding Hill Farm', which operates a campsite near Hadrian's Wall (paragraph 25(1)).

WCF filed its VAT return for the period ended 11/23 on time, claiming a repayment of £4,445.16, and filed its VAT return for the period ended 01/24 on time, showing a balance payable to HMRC of £5,318.67. WCF paid £1,021.77 on 09 February 2024, leaving a balance of £4,296.90 at the centre of the dispute (paragraph 21).

WCF became aware of problems with its VAT account in spring 2025, upon receiving late payment penalties for periods 07/23 to 10/23. Investigation revealed HMRC had failed to record various payments and had not processed WCF's returns for periods 11/23 and 11/24. HMRC eventually cancelled the earlier penalties but charged the two penalties under appeal on 16 November 2025 and 07 March 2026 (paragraph 25(4)).

Core dispute

The central issue was whether WCF was entitled, under section 25(4) VATA 1994, to offset the VAT repayment claimed for the period ended 11/23 against the VAT liability for the period ended 01/24, such that no VAT was paid late and the penalties should be set aside (paragraph 23).

Alternatively, WCF argued that its mistaken belief that it could offset the amounts, and/or HMRC's errors and omissions in failing to process the repayment until March 2026, amounted to a reasonable excuse, or alternatively constituted special circumstances justifying reduction of the penalties to zero (paragraph 23).

HMRC's position was that the balance of £4,296.90 was not paid until March 2026, that it was therefore paid late, and that the penalties had been properly charged, with no reasonable excuse or special circumstances applicable (paragraph 24).

A further issue, raised by WCF shortly before the hearing, was whether the second late payment penalty had been issued outside the two-year statutory time limit (paragraph 55). A separate issue arose from HMRC's non-attendance at the hearing and its subsequent application to set aside the decision.

Court findings

The Tribunal found that reasonable steps had been taken to notify HMRC of the hearing and that it was in the interests of justice to proceed in HMRC's absence under Rule 33 (paragraphs 9 to 15).

On the substantive issue, the Tribunal held, applying Tradecorp and DCM (Optical Holdings), that only a repayment claim that has been admitted or upheld by HMRC can be credited by a taxpayer against VAT due under section 25(4) VATA 1994. Since HMRC did not admit the 11/23 repayment claim until March 2026, WCF was not entitled to offset it earlier, and the VAT for period 01/24 was therefore paid late, meaning the penalties had been correctly charged (paragraphs 32 to 37).

Applying the four-stage test from Christine Perrin v HMRC, the Tribunal found that WCF held a genuine and objectively reasonable belief that it was entitled to offset the repayment claim, reinforced by HMRC's historical prompt processing of repayments, HMRC's failure to verify the claim as envisaged in Tradecorp, and HMRC's failure to chase for the outstanding sum. This amounted to a reasonable excuse that continued until HMRC admitted the 11/23 repayment claim in March 2026 (paragraphs 42 to 50).

The Tribunal stated, obiter, that had it been necessary to decide, it would have found special circumstances existed under paragraphs 13 and 21(3) of Schedule 26 FA 2021, that HMRC's decision not to reduce the penalties was flawed, and that it would have substituted its own decision to reduce the penalties to zero, criticising the nearly two-year application of a 4% annual penalty rate caused by HMRC's own processing failures (paragraphs 52 to 54).

On the subsequent Rule 38 application, Judge Smith accepted that HMRC's representative had been involved in a road traffic accident the day before the hearing, but found it was not in the interests of justice to set aside the decision. This was because HMRC had a large legal team and could have sent another representative or sought an adjournment, HMRC's written submissions were detailed, the hearing's oral component would have been limited, and the outcome was not finely balanced (paragraphs 5 to 15 of the set-aside decision).

Outcome

The Tribunal allowed WCF's appeal, finding that although the VAT had been paid late in a technical sense, WCF had a reasonable excuse for the late payment, and the penalties under appeal were set aside (paragraph 51).

The Tribunal did not need to determine the special circumstances argument or the time-limit argument concerning the second penalty, given its finding on reasonable excuse (paragraphs 52 and 55).

In a separate decision, Judge Smith refused HMRC's application, treated as made under Rule 38 of the Tribunal Procedure Rules, to set aside the Tribunal's decision on the basis of HMRC's non-attendance at the hearing (paragraph 15 of the set-aside decision).

Major issues / areas of contention

  • Whether it was in the interests of justice to proceed with the hearing in HMRC's absence under Rule 33 of the Tribunal Procedure Rules.
  • Whether WCF was entitled under section 25(4) VATA 1994 to offset its unadmitted VAT repayment claim for period 11/23 against its VAT liability for period 01/24, such that no VAT was paid late.
  • The application of the distinction between admitted/upheld and unadmitted VAT credit claims as set out in R (Tradecorp) v Customs and Excise Commissioners and DCM (Optical Holdings) Limited v HMRC.
  • Whether WCF had a reasonable excuse for the late payment under paragraph 12(1) of Schedule 26 FA 2021, applying the test in Christine Perrin v HMRC.
  • Whether, obiter, special circumstances existed under paragraphs 13 and 21(3) of Schedule 26 FA 2021 justifying reduction of the penalties to zero.
  • Whether the second late payment penalty was issued outside the two-year statutory time limit (not determined).
  • Whether HMRC's post-hearing application to set aside the decision under Rule 38, following its representative's non-attendance due to a road traffic accident, should be granted.